My brain has been eating thought experiments like this for years.
We can simplify it with the universe itself. God is such a lame backstory to these experiments, we shove Him into a corner.
It involves the basic concepts of the line segment, line, and ray from maths.
The universe, in our three-dimensional thinking, is in one of three states.
It has a beginning and end (line segment), a beginning with no end (ray), or no beginning or end (line).
In none of these three states can a creator exist, because in each of these three states it will either negate it's existence (line segment and ray), or negate the existence of the idea of a creator (line).
I am proposing that the domain of faith comprises the entire domain of imagination. Within this domain arises a new set of "laws" that generally predict how the smallest of particles will behave. It gets blurry: Is it a wave of light, or, is it a particle. Is it a particle, or a wave of light? How much of that depends on the observer?
I'm saying this domain ("the world", "hell") is vast enough that anyone who does not have full and total knowledge could easily get "lost". I propose that math, and the laws of physics, are entirely part of the domain of faith/imagination, and are utterly foreign concepts in the domain of knowledge/Christ.
So you have to be careful about thought experiments that start and stop within this domain, and don't have any reach beyond the domain. Better to focus on the concept of mutually exclusive existence by considering conditions that cannot coexist, like:
Life/death
Knowledge/Faith
Oneness/Particles (partitions, separations, unique identity, inequality)
The conflation between knowledge and faith is really a stickler for most people. You can't even be a person without having first confused the difference between the two. So we have to be very careful about observing phenomenon that arises out of faith, and presuming we can derive some kind of knowledge from it. As people, we are biased toward further conflation, because deep down, we realize knowledge threatens our perceived existence as a unique being.
Yer the one that made me remember it.