- What stock was that?
- I assume the stock tanked 15% or so after an earnings report?
![]()
That's right. AMBA. Revs and EPS were great, guidance was terrible.
- What stock was that?
- I assume the stock tanked 15% or so after an earnings report?
![]()
Sorry, I just noticed the size of the account. It's great that you are making those returns, but I assume this is not a full time endeavor for you.
Hey there Eighteen. Thought I'd chime in here as a new user as well [ was actually researching some issues on the internet with MA taxation on short term gains for my taxes and came across this forum ]
I too have an annualized 3 year return that is doing much better than the pros ( I'm at 39% ) and I used to think this was good until I asked a few professionals. It was hard for them to not laugh in my face. I registered here to give you some input about what they said about my trading and maybe it applies to you:
1. I'm trading a $620,000 book and take on an incredible amount of risk in order to make these returns (actually I no longer trade like this see #5). There are "returns" and then there are "risk adjusted returns" Its a huge difference
2. Best day trading win was around $42,000. Biggest wins last year were two biotechs, both around $98K. Biggest loss was around $9,000 and then worst month was ($17,600).
3. There is something called "value at risk" and its worth exploring. In my book I rarely hold more than 2-3 stocks and positions range from a few days to at most 3-4 weeks.
4. The most I've had in the market at one time was about $320,000. This is the part about risk. I had $250,000 in one stock ( TNXP back in May 2015 ) and then the rest in like 2 other stocks. Also I wasn't hedged on this at all so my risk was sky high. It sucked trying to sleep at night.
5. I do not use leverage at all nor do I trade short. That being said, last year I traded very thinly traded biotechs and could get out in case I needed too but that all stopped in Jan 2016 when I had to take a $21,000 hit. My worst month ever. So now I'm all about trading stocks that at least have 300,000 shares trade per day.
My 2016 is horrible as I'm about -3.5% and I'm trading a ton. But the big part is this: my trading over the last 3 years has been astonishing, but its not steady. I'm up and down all over the place and nobody would want that done to their portfolio. Also and this is the biggest thing....its much much harder to do this once you are moving a few million here and there.
You can swing around sub $500,000 portfolios pretty easy these days and even swim in waters where hedge funds cannot due to liquidity which gives you an edge now, but when you have more money its harder to do since you'd need to increase the number of positions you hold.
Best thing to do would be to show consistent returns every month with minimal draw downs. Its the consistency that matters most not like me winning and crashing all over the place.
Normally I apply 20% or less of my buying power to each trade. I do not use stops for swing trades (although I can see how stops would be necessary for day-trading). Profit-taking varies from trade to trade depending on the situation. Some trades I might look for 1% profit, others I might look for 10%, or anywhere in between, depending on what I know when I enter the trade.
If you are producing those kinds of returns then, the probabilities of loss will most likely catch up with you ...
- Don't quit your day job.
- Take some of that "house" money that you've generated and open and fund a Roth IRA. The tax deferral will help compound assets over taxable much faster.
- Gravitate towards holding longer term. Use academically and empirically proven ( by Nobel laureates ) research and invest in stock universes that have produced the highest alpha premium of all stock universes over decades *.
For example, in applying simple, quantitative variables within a tactical framework using the large / small cap value universes, utilities sector, and cash equivalents has produced robust returns over 35 years with a couple transactions a year
http://tinyurl.com/goeqe7o
* https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kToqLWLISRk4n4YnSzv1hT5kBN54l5CvhwGgDwJKPJI/edit?usp=sharing
James
Director Quantitative Research
20% so you may have a maximum of 5 trades on at any one time.
When you say depending on the situation regarding taking profits I'm not sure how you will continue getting consistent returns without a consistent way to manage.
I don't like stops in fact if you had used them you may have had negative returns. It looks like in the past you were long when you opened the trade and you waited until it was profitable to close. Your risk was undefined without stops. The problem with stops is your holding until your wrong rather than holding until your right. Or if you have a profit target you are doing both at once.
One thing options can do for you is you can wait until your right while limiting your risk at the same time. So its like a stop except if your wrong then your right you profit, with a stop if your wrong at any time its over for a loss. If I understand properly your trades did not have any protection and you were fortunate that none of your trades tanked. Because if they did that's a possible 20% draw down for each position.
I recommend learning how to put on trades that define risk yet give you time to be right. I like to risk 10-20% per trade but with a very high probability of profit. To increase your probabilities your can exit early and take only a percent of maximum potential profit. There are also ways to increase your probabilities by lowering basis. Its a learning curve worth putting the time into.
If you are producing those kinds of returns then, the probabilities of loss will most likely catch up with you ..
Thanks for the advice, James!
I do have one question. It seems you are implying that my probability of loss is directly related to, or influenced by, my level of returns. Pardon my ignorance but, how does that work?

I have been trading stocks at the retail level for just over 3 years. I am averaging about 23% returns annually, mostly swing-trading. I made 25% in 2015. Is this any good? Or, do I have work to do?