Search results

If I could add just a simple question and one that I was reminded of reading that first link. A student was using candlestick charts, but was told to convert to bar charts since that's what's used in the SCT method. What's the reason for this? As far as I know, both candlesticks and bars show...

Thank you very much, @WchPl! That's generous of you. I'll take a quick look now, but will have to archive it for futures studies as time is in short supply at the moment. Best regards.

Thanks, @Sprout. :)

Appreciate your comment, @Sprout. What would you (and others reading) recommend if one would want to actually study Jack's teachings...? Is it best to simply search up all his posts on his various and start going through it all from A to Z? I know he had at least two usernames (Jack Hershey...

That's a very generous and interesting reply, Sprout. Thank you. I wouldn't mind seeing a screenshot of your screens if that's something you'd care to share, although you described it so precisely that it's really not necessary. I am considering investing in Jigsaw myself. Since I have NT as...

If it's not too much to ask (or maybe someone have done it already), is it possible to get a summary of Jack's methodology or concepts? Maybe those of you who study it can take it on as a nice homework to further your understanding. I've picked up a few bits and pieces over the years though, so...

Thank you for sharing your experiences. It is interesting. The point is simply that if someone makes claims and takes on the role of teaching or being a guru, I don't think it's too much to ask for some proof. Both Jack and other disciples have posted extensively on ET with thousands of posts...

Is it too much to ask for any links where I can find this? As far as I know there haven't been any, but it's quite possible I have simply missed it. Seems like a stretch to me. Is there anyone outside ET who even know who this is? As for 'proof', I have myself 'followed' someone who have not...

10K isn't a problem to me, but their day trading margins (ES) are simply too high for me starting out. And no, I'm not looking to utilize $400 day trading margins either.

Interesting thread. I always found what I read of Jack's work interesting, but I never really delved into it myself. I don't rule out doing so in the future as some of the general principles seems to align with mine. I'm curious though. Is any of you guys making any money on this? Have there...

Can be or is...? :) Are you using any particular orderflow software yourself? I've looked briefly into the Jigsaw DOM and it does seem like a huge improvement upon most DOMS (in my case: Ninja's). As for the book, I'm well into it and find that I already know a lot of the material intuitively...

Thank you for your comment, SkyChef. It's generous of you to share as much as you do. CL is a fairly different market from the ES and more suitable for your trading style. I'm now reading the BS trading book and I'm already noting some BS comments that I flat out disagree with, but I am...

Oh, my bad. Well, if you look at the ES today: +10,75 (60 minutes) -15,00 (68 minutes) +7,00 (61 minutes) -6,75 (181 minutes) Not every day is as generous as today though. But basically, I'm interested in trading these type of swings or the high/low difference on less volatile days.

Roughly 6 years on this specific methodology, but have been following and studying the markets on/off for well over 10 years now.

I use a Logitech Anywhere 2 which I think is pretty nice. I bought the Master also, but found it too big for my hands. That said, I did try a gaming mouse while at the mall with my nephew and it seemed like another level. My Anywhere seems precise enough, but that gaming mouse was something else.

So, I actually bought the basic course. I think I paid 85$ which isn't a big investment to me. The biggest investment is the time spent learning this material. Having spent a long time on other parts of my methodology, I now have more time for this and I think it will be a nice addition to my...

Thank you, SkyChef. Can you elaborate a bit on that comment?

Sure. The futures markets are zero sum. I don't think anyone would argue that fact. But, you're assuming that every operator is looking to make a profit in the futures market which simply isn't the case. At any given point in time there's people trading on different time frames and with very...

Not everyone participating in the futures market are looking to make a profit per se. Remember that the primary function of the futures market is to hedge and control risk from your other positions. Speculation is secondary. As long as there is liquidity, you're not really competing against anyone.

Thank you, maxinger. Same to you! :)