Search results

First, I sincerely apologize for letting emotions get in the way of my progress and everyone elses. In my quest for understanding and truth, I have let nastiness get in the way. Believe it or not, I am profoundly sorry. Perhaps the whole thing is a matter of communication misunderstanding. In...

This is utter hogwash. We're talking during the first lesson. I was in the air the first lesson. Once again you have ignored or twisted my words and questions. You have again just ignored stuff over and over and over. I suppose when I post a video of PRV showing exactly what we ALL experience...

As an instructor I'd kick myself. Because there are rules for exactly what you state. They are all based on Newtons laws of motion.

First you said it wasn't possible. NOw you claim it's an extreme situation. WHich is it? I am honestly open to do what you suggest. You have made this suggestion over and over. Not once have you suggests how to proceed doing so. I real teacher would do this, not just reiterate an instruction...

Wrong, I am a pilot. Multi-instrument. The first day I spent 45min on the ground and 45 in the air.

Spyder, here is an example. I don't think anyone would argue against this as too statistically out there. PRV = (bar length X current volume)/(time elapsed) Prior bar's volume was 14,000 1 minute into current bar volume is 3,000 which is 15,000 on a PRV basis and thus PRV is increasing...

Spyder, YOu continue to twist my words and avoid answering my questions. I never said a bar that has no volume. I said a bar that more volume stops coming into. You have no idea how much confusion you create for many of us when you say "absolutely for sure 100%" and then use the word...

Ivo, sorry, I missed this earlier. You hit the nail on the head. It feels EXACTLY like I'm guessing, all the time, even at bar end. I have carved out two possible routes to not guessing. One, (the preferred path) is that an expert demonstrates how it works. I understand that's not...

I happen to be a pilot. I never suggested soloing immediatlely. But the fact is you're in the cockpit from the first lesson. And what if students questions are ignored? I'm not talking about jumping ahead. I'm talking about unresolved basic stuff. I'm not anxious to move forward, I'm anxious...

It helps immensely. It assists the student in seeing the big picture. It assists the student in understanding how the pieces fit together. It assists the student not wandering off course. It provides confidence. And more. I have instructed in the fields of sports car racing, salesmanship...

You've given me so many different sets of things to do at different times that I truly am confused as to what it is I'm supposed to be doing with what data at what times. Let's get something straight: you are willing to share but you certainly aren't teaching. Handing out information how you...

I thought it best to really make clear what I don't comprehend. You stated... ******* At some point within the five minute bar, you know you cannot have change because, based on current PRV, actual volume will go beyond the previous volume bar. ******** This is just patently false. It's so...

Let's say I accept what you just wrote here. What do I do with it? Is this ONLY for bar to bar continuation/change assessment, or is this for determining FTT/flaw? Your mentioning the "40%" level implies I'm supposed to be using this for flaw ident. But then how do I deal with the rougly 30%...

Stating absolutes without qualification is confusing the hell out of people who have brains that work like mine. :) If what you say is so, then how come see (fairly often) bars with wider range and equal or lower volume (friday had 6 such bars). Would you please describe how you know when...

Let me try rephrasing... I understand it's ridiculous to ask for a rule that states look at PRV at so many minutes into the bar, etc etc. But, somehow, you must have some sort of unconscious algorithm that tells you when to look at PRV. Cause looking at it all the time does not work.

Sarcasm is not appreciated. I'm taking the heat for a number of people who have the same difficulty as I have. Your post completely misses the point of everything I've been saying. If you really care, you'll respond to this specifically. Lets take one you say, step by step, in real time...

http://pr0crast.com/downloads/videos/instructional/Channels.For.Beginners-bundlemaker.wmv

I don't know how much more plain I can be than to state I MUST have interpretted incorrectly. That is a given. If I thought otherwise, would it make sense for me to even be typing right now? Communication is the LEAST effective means to teach anything, or for that matter to convey anything...

Ivo, With all due respect, you've regurgitated, you haven't thought it out. Again, I ask, what does it mean whether you have a dip, or a stall, or a hitch or an HVS? Not is it one? but does it matter which one? Your second sentence is circular. Knowing something is X can not, by common logic...

Here's another one: "what do I need for this to be an FTT (change) and what do I need for this to be a flaw (continuation)?" Let's say I answer that question based on the most current MADA cycle, meaning, right now. My answer is hold and is based on the close of a 5min ES bar and is coarse in...