Search results

  1. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    Again I do not mind hindsight charts, I only do backtests and then going walk-foward to see if there is an edge. I could not find any edge here.
  2. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    It still can bounce several times or 10 times to non defined swings above and below any Fibo level. So how do you do that when trading it ? You could get many whipsaws here, which can cost you a lot of money, especially in choppy markets.
  3. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    I know Fibos as I have backtested retracements but with not good results at all. That is why I am curious anyone can explain they are really good working ? Tell me something about your stats when trading with Fibos ?
  4. TrAndy2022

    Why the heck is even GOLD going down?!

    Not on that scale of course. You need to go to the minute or hourly time frame. Then you see the correlation if you put them on same chart as overlay.
  5. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    I can understand it if you use Fibs as exit point where you have your stoploss or takeprofit. Once it is hit then it is exit. But for entries ?
  6. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    But what is a level ? It is certain point, exact point measured on Fibo. So how much do you allow then to move up and above that exact point to be a so called additional indicator for your trading ? Just imagine it moves 1 point or 2 pips above and below 10 times. What do you do ?
  7. TrAndy2022

    Why the heck is even GOLD going down?!

    Gold is correlated with AUDUSD, so when the market goes down, it also means in short term that to some extent AUDUSD and Gold goes lower too. All markets are interconnected to each other by the way. So this is nothing special.
  8. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    The question is how do you trade Fibos ? You have calculated the exact point here. Then it moves a tick above or below and then whipsaws and non defined vola how often do you then reverse your position ? So you add 3% above and below as extra stop here ? Does it work really ? How often then you...
  9. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    ... ...and how profitable is it for you to ask it in different shape ? What is your profit factor ? Your monthly RRR, if you do not care for RRR on individual trades ? Because if Fibonacci has a real edge than the numbers trading it should be looking very good. Otherwise it is more random and...
  10. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    ...just hindsight or ? If you do market replay and go forward what is your average RRR and win rate then ?
  11. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    ...and what is your average Reward-to-Risk-Ratio and your average winning rate ? Do you trade FX majors or anything else with Fibs ?
  12. TrAndy2022

    Fibs don't work

    Who is trading after Fibonacci ? Only small retailers I guess, maybe some bank traders, but not far enough to move the market(s). So I assume a 'system' around Fibo cannot be really effective, achieving high sharpes. Anyone proof me wrong here ?
  13. TrAndy2022

    Will Forex work if the Atlantic internet cable blows up

    I also would say it can only affect your latency. If you reside in heart of Europe, than London which is the main hub here is not far away. So this is more an issue for overseas scalper I might guess. There is always a route, you cannot shut down the internet. Thus you can always trade forex if...
  14. TrAndy2022

    How probably is a collapse of Euro currency possible within 9 to 18 months ?

    Is it possible with higher interest rates going to 5% or 6% in spring next year in Euro area too (assumption is that the inflation is still out of control and do not come back to much lower levels), that Greece, Portugal, maybe then Spain and Italy needs to drop out of Euro currency, which is...
  15. TrAndy2022

    I keep cutting my winners

    Did you try Renko Charts as help ? Usually most traders hold longer in the trades and making also less trades.
  16. TrAndy2022

    Longtime prop trader says 4% of day traders made decent money

    How much do the best prop traders make? A prop trader makes between $42,373 and $793,331, depending on their skills and experience. The median salary for prop traders is $203,679. Middle 57% earn between $203,679 and $400,084. The top 86% make $793,331. A beginner prop trader can do much less at...
  17. TrAndy2022

    Longtime prop trader says 4% of day traders made decent money

    Some interesting studies about the percentage of (consistent) profitable traders here. I have attached the corresponding studies. The Cross-Section of Speculator Skill.pdf 522 KB This paper seeks to understand the differentiating factors between successful and unsuccessful day traders in...
  18. TrAndy2022

    Swing Traders: What are your monthly returns?

    No I traded with 1 to 0.33 leverage so far less than 1:1 leverage so I made 1.5% with 1:1 lever.
  19. TrAndy2022

    Swing Traders: What are your monthly returns?

    So I had several months with +10% and more. But you can watch my progress in my journal. Time will tell if I can hold this.
  20. TrAndy2022

    Swing Traders: What are your monthly returns?

    Several trades but far below 1:1 leverage I used so far, so very low risk.
Back
Top