Zumo and Generic trade

Is there any reason to chose one over the other for futures trading? Besides the 9 cent difference in commissions that is (They are both FCMs of Ironbeam) Any feedback would be appreciated. :)
 
If you are only going to trade the liquid futures mentioned above, they might be OK.

The price is right, but I downloaded a demo of the FireTip software in Oct or Nov (from Zumo) and was underwhelmed. They said they had just upgraded it but I didn't like it. The charts were bare bones with only a handful of adjustments/indicators and they were poorly designed - a lot of wasted space at the bottom of each chart.

The quote/watch lists were OK, the DOM seemed fast enough, but I only tried it with a couple of simple fake orders.

They had some pre-formatted futures spreads which could be a time saver, but what made me lose interest completely were their options chains, or lack thereof. No impl vol, no greeks, and a complicated, slow way of finding the (basic) chains in the first place.

So, if you're a short term trader and the price is what attracts you, maybe they're worth a shot, but they're not the place for trade research, for options, or for trade mgmt/portfolio review.
 
Brighton-thanks for the reply :D I only trade futures outright,no options,so maybe it will be O.K. Anyone else?
 
I still have an account at Generic Trade and do mostly Indices and Currencies - just futures. The platforms do not have as many features as Ninja or TT that I've used before, but for my kind of trading (100-500/day off of dome), their 'Generic Trader Pro' has worked out well for me.
 
Back
Top