I wonder if we are talking about the same thing here.
When I hear "You Only Need $5000 to Make a Living", I take that to mean that any time your account is significantly over $5000 you withdraw the difference.
That's not the same thing as starting with $5000 and building it up to a point where you can then make a living.
Also, if you have other savings or income which you can use to replenish your account in the event of a drawdown, that's not the same as making a living off only $5000 either.
When I hear "You Only Need $5000 to Make a Living", I take that to mean that any time your account is significantly over $5000 you withdraw the difference.
That's not the same thing as starting with $5000 and building it up to a point where you can then make a living.
Also, if you have other savings or income which you can use to replenish your account in the event of a drawdown, that's not the same as making a living off only $5000 either.