I don't watch Jim Cramer on CNBC too often but did catch the first 10 minutes of his show last night. He spent several minutes harshly criticizing XOM, explained why he didn't like it and why Chevron and others are better companies to invest in. And then he said . . . "BUY XOM!"
The reason is that mutual funds have decided they want window dressing to show exposure to oil, but not being fully committed to the commodity, have chosen XOM since it's diversified and can do well even if oil falls. These mutual fund families have to make large buys of XOM to get a decent position, thus driving the price up. This then leads to XOM being a higher percentage of the S&P index (which is market cap weighted), thus leading to more purchasing by index funds.
Will XOM get back to $74. Probably, but how long do you want to wait? Cramer thinks it will trend higher through year end.