Quote from murray t turtle:
Maybe right on ATM,riskarb, but they can turn into ITM quickly ;
have done better buying overall on ITM, so far.Maybe proves your point.
It's not a point of maybe. Gamma decreases as it trades ITM. Yes, you made my point, but not for the reason you state. I wasn't making an issue of delta or marked-loss; I was making an issue of short gamma/vol. Sell a straddle if you want to trade into a declining gamma-position. In the majority of cases, the big money losses occured by selling stops in cheap gamma[OTM]. ATM gamma is expensive. It's all about the curvature. OTM options carry small-initial gammas, but their dgamma[leverage] is extraordinary.
OTM options are cheap... $prem and gamma/dgamma. Vol is often meaningless when referring to option under 10 deltas as the difference between the bidIV&askIV can exceed the vol-line at ThVal. Not as much of an issue in today's markets, but take a look at some deeps in Copper options sometime. BidIV 20% ... askIV 70%, ThVal at 45%. This was a quote a while ago from a buddy recalling the market he made for a customer who was trying to move 10lots in Cu options. Hilarious.
In answer to the original post in this thread. I know of two individuals who have earned > $5mil/year trading short gamma exclusively. Not to say that they never bought an option, but to be exclusively short gamma. Both were upstairs exchange members. "JS" would sell atm combos on Friday's opening rotation, buying them back on Monday's close or converting them to iron flys. "TS" would attempt to package his edge in coverting all positions in long flys by the EOD. If his book contained any extraneous exposure he'd offset at the close; the only overnight exposure consisted of long flys. "JS" is worth North of $30mil and retired before 40 in Aspen. TS still trades, and had a string of years > $7mil.
I am not advocating buying otm gamma as a strategy, but I'd certainly rather sell one atm at $10 then sell 10 otm at $1. When option deltas = stock you're in trouble with that 10lot.