Quote from exQQQQseme:
Cohenmichaela, the rule isn't all that surprising when one stops to realize that the rules are written by lawyers not options traders. But, ya know what? Even though I know exactly where you're coming from, I also feel more comfortable shorting the stocks and writing puts against them, than I would feel simply shorting calls.
Perhaps it's because I have more flexibility to screw around. For example if I wanted to do a short 450 or 500 and sell 4 Puts, it's easily accomplished. Same regarding my propensity to occasionally pick up some calls to satisfy a temporary desire for some positive deltas.
Finally, there's the over riding consideration of the Implied Volatility. When faced with the ongoing question of whether to buy calls or write puts, no doubt you and I, as experienced options traders take a look at the present IV situation.
Anyway, your posting is very much appreciated. Thanks.
Bob