Wrangle Long and Short

the wrangle has similar gamma characteristics to the straddle

This is simply untrue. Just take this simple example, suppose you've entered a position ATMF. Gamma is going to be the same for puts/call, let's say gamma = g. Then the gamma of a straddle will be 2*g (or -2*g for short). In a wrangle you're long both ratio spreads for calls and puts, so let's say short both ATMF calls and puts which will put you at -2*g gamma, however you've purchased 2x in the wings which will bring your gamma down close to zero.

Another way to look at the wrangle is the cost of trading vega convexity.
 
Back
Top