Would Obama have the audacity to apply his logic to a professional athlete?

Quote from denner:
Seriously, trying to argue against Tiger Woods or MJ's success as a case of hard work and determination is obscene.
True, but the version of 80/20 rule applies here too - determination and hard work make up for 80% of their success. Raw talent and (in large part) luck is what makes them the champions. Oh, and don't forget about steroids, of course!
 
im certainly no barack hussein obama fan (do we really have a president named hussein :p) but it sounded like he was talking about the roads and bridges as far as the building part of the quote.

"somebody invested in roads and bridges, if you got a business, you didn't build that"

thats the exact quote, i could be wrong.
 
Quote from sle:

True, but the version of 80/20 rule applies here too - determination and hard work make up for 80% of their success. Raw talent and (in large part) luck is what makes them the champions. Oh, and don't forget about steroids, of course!

You are absolutely correct. Talent is an enormous advantage and it's usually what makes all the hard work worth it.

Granted, comparing MJ to Tiger isn't even the best analogy. At their respective peaks, it makes sense, but their path's to greatness were quite different...considering that MJ didn't even emerge as a college prospect until sometime in his junior year of high school.

Tiger, OTOH, played in his first PGA Tour event in his junior year of high school and was cleaning up on the junior circuit.
 
Quote from Max E. Pad:

The fact of the matter is that the reason they are successful is SPECIFICALLY BECAUSE they were smarter, and they worked harder, its not a goddamn fluke, and it had nothing to do with the government.....

So if Tiger was born 15 years earlier in history; he would've made it into pro-golf?

Not picking a fight here, just asking you what you think about this given pro-golf's history.
 
Quote from ChkitOut:

im certainly no barack hussein obama fan (do we really have a president named hussein :p) but it sounded like he was talking about the roads and bridges as far as the building part of the quote.

"somebody invested in roads and bridges, if you got a business, you didn't build that"

thats the exact quote, i could be wrong.
You are correct, thank you for being honest. Obama's error there was that of the "dangling modifier". Composition 101 error.
 
Quote from denner:

He was born to a relatively poor family. His dad wasn't exactly "rolling in it". He played golf at the local muni and much of the help along the way came about because the kid was so damn good at such a young age that teaching pro's, coaches etc were lining up to hitch a ride.

He was awarded a golf scholarship to a private university...

Well, relatively poor is one thing. Being born in a ghetto is another. I would place Tiger's upbringing as stable (his dad was together and *there* to guide him), secure and middle class.

There are probably quite a few potential "Tigers" out there.... but, we'll never get to see them reach that potential as a result of poverty, poor family values and a lack of community.

Personally, Tiger is inspirational in many ways to me; his work ethic is world class as is his emotional temperment. My point here is not to take away from Tiger's accomplishments; but to shine some light on the impact environment has on the individual. Its a significant impact in my opinion, much more so than people would care to admit.
 
Quote from Mike805:

So if Tiger was born 15 years earlier in history; he would've made it into pro-golf?

Not picking a fight here, just asking you what you think about this given pro-golf's history.

Lee Elder, Jim Dent, Calvin Peete were PGA Tour Pro's and black. They were all around 15 years prior to Tiger Woods turning pro.
 
Quote from denner:

Lee Elder, Jim Dent, Calvin Peete were PGA Tour Pro's and black. They were all around 15 years prior to Tiger Woods turning pro.

Please expand on this. I'm not sure what you're getting at.
 
Quote from Mike805:

Please expand on this. I'm not sure what you're getting at.

Your comment about "15 years prior" would Tiger Woods have made it? I'm not sure what was intended, but from the look of it, I assumed you were commenting on his race and the obstacles towards playing professional golf in a tradtionally white sport.

I wanted to make clear that there were several prominent and successful black golfers in the 1960's,70's, 80's...but maybe you weren't implying that after all.
 
Quote from Mike805:

Please expand on this. I'm not sure what you're getting at.
He's providing examples of black golfers who made it without beginning in favorable circumstances. This is an attempt to weaken the argument that environment is important (which of course goes back to Obama's statement re infrastructure). Here is where you get to trot out statistics, which is a beautiful moment since he loves using statistics to demonize blacks in the first place.
 
Back
Top