Woodie's CCI exposed by former moderator

Quote from RedDuke:

If anyone still does not understand why indicators(like CCI, market depth and many others) on non fixed time fractals charts (volume, range or tick) are neither leading nor lagging, please reread Jack's posts on this thread. They represent, THE NOW, and will help you to make the right decision if you know what you doing of course.

Sorry, we aint buying crazy today - we're full up
 
Exactly! Studying Jack's teachings is always wise. And SCT goes far beyond these indicators. Jack wrote:

SCT usues a paradigm that is related to pool extraction and is effected by using three skill based approaches: effectiviness, efficiency and optimization. To do these kinds of things conventional platforms and screen displays are not possible.

Eagerly Awaiting His Continued Tutelage,

Pool Extraction Paradigm Fan Club

Quote from RedDuke:

If anyone still does not understand why indicators(like CCI, market depth and many others) on non fixed time fractals charts (volume, range or tick) are neither leading nor lagging, please reread Jack's posts on this thread. They represent, THE NOW, and will help you to make the right decision if you know what you doing of course.

Regards,
redduke
 
Quote from PEP Fan Club:

Exactly! Studying Jack's teachings is always wise. And SCT goes far beyond these indicators. Jack wrote:

SCT usues a paradigm that is related to pool extraction and is effected by using three skill based approaches: effectiviness, efficiency and optimization. To do these kinds of things conventional platforms and screen displays are not possible.

Eagerly Awaiting His Continued Tutelage,

Pool Extraction Paradigm Fan Club
"Crazy" Jack Hershey Holds Court


CrazyManT-shirt.jpg
 
Quote from PEP Fan Club:

Exactly! Studying Jack's teachings is always wise. And SCT goes far beyond these indicators. Jack wrote:

SCT usues a paradigm that is related to pool extraction and is effected by using three skill based approaches: effectiviness, efficiency and optimization. To do these kinds of things conventional platforms and screen displays are not possible.

Eagerly Awaiting His Continued Tutelage,

Pool Extraction Paradigm Fan Club

Exactly! Jack teaching (for those who can actually understand) are the closest thing possible to the word of god.

If you want to empty a lake, what will you do? Use a spoon? or go and build a giant pump? which will be more efficient? And if you are one of those detractors (watching us build the pump while bitching continuously) you can go fornicate yourself with a iron stick
 
Quote from HedgefndTrader2:

Exactly! Jack teaching (for those who can actually understand) are the closest thing possible to the word of god.

If you want to empty a lake, what will you do? Use a spoon? or go and build a giant pump? which will be more efficient? And if you are one of those detractors (watching us build the pump while bitching continuously) you can go fornicate yourself with a iron stick
Sorry, we aint buying crazy today - we're all full up
 
Was this about CCI or "Woodies CCI"?

Woodies CCI is a system of CCI patterns.
CCI is just an indicator - so when people say CCI works - of course! It is a calculation using historical prices as input (I never saw a CCI with a setting of "1"), so as long as there are enough reference bars, CCI calculates and "works".

But do Woodies CCI patterns (shapes and forms the CCI takes that he qualifies and uses to enter trades) give a statistical edge?

The "Famir" looks like a failed ZLR. But if you have another named pattern for every pattern that fails, doesn't that pretty much guarantee that you will be able to say one of them worked?
 
Quote from MarketMasher:


The "Famir" looks like a failed ZLR. But if you have another named pattern for every pattern that fails, doesn't that pretty much guarantee that you will be able to say one of them worked?

Exactly, for every failed pattern they just kept coming up with another name.. the triple lindy shamu with a half pike twist :p
 
Quote from RedDuke:

Hi Hombre,

You do not really need any indicators to trade successfully. Price action, time&sales and market depth is all that is needed. However, indicator can help you to see price action patterns much quicker. The reason I use CCI it to be able to react faster.

For example. There is CCI pattern that is called Famir (used to be called shamu). What this pattern means is the price originally rejected a level and then changed the direction again (looks like letter z turned 90%). I can see all of this just by looking at price action, but it is even more clearer with CCI, and I want to be able to analyze and react as fast as possible. I trade intra day with high frequency so quick decisions matter to me a lot.

Regards,
redduke

Thank Duke,
What seting works good for Famir( both charts and cci ) ? What is your opinion on CCI divergences ?
Thanks,
 
Quote from Hombre:

Thank Duke,
What seting works good for Famir( both charts and cci ) ? What is your opinion on CCI divergences ?
Thanks,

It will depend on the market and your goals. I personally use 144 volume chart for DAX. CCI setting is standard - 14.

I do not trade divergences.

Regards,
redduke
 
Back
Top