Quote from themickey:
MACD is one of the worst indicators imo.
Of all indicators it seems to get the most mention but is the most useless.
Maybe it works on something like an index but for stocks it is random.
IMO, you can't use MACD on a 10c stock and a $2 stock as they behave differently.
MACD will give the appearance of working but it's because you are looking at a trending stock. Soon as there is chop MACD is useless.
BTW, a trend is only seen on hindsight, just like Elliot Wave and nearly every other indicator.
Volatility is a better indicator I believe but that also has its limitations.
OBV is yet another but again limited in its use.
I do not personally use MACD to signal a trend. I was only responding to a question about how to use it in conjunction with %R. However, MACD is no worse than any other moving average to define a trend. I prefer price action and trend line breaks to define trends.
There are a lot of different ways to use MACD besides signaling a trend. That is only the most basic use. I like it principally for divergence signals on a lower time frame in the direction of the trend on a higher time frame.
I am curious what method of trading you find to be effective in chop?
I am also very interested in the use of volatility in trading and would be interested in how you use it.