Nice one, Wagg. I asked my gf this question once (wdww), and she said in the order of:
"You'll never figure it. Because, for starters it's very hard to explain to a man want a woman wants, since men have no idea how to communicate or comprehend on this level. On top of that, every woman wants something completely different. So you'll never be able to figure a general conclusion. But you see - That's what makes us interesting." Nice!
My own 5 cents to this thread:
Well, it's very difficult to
scalp (NASDAQ) stocks in real life now, it's almost impossible to do this in a high-performance fashion unless you have a condo in NYC, across Wall St, with a ping to your broker of maybe 30ms, a T1-line and X_Trader on a 3.6GhZ workstation and a prop account with no commissions and ECN rebates maybe. I used to trade stocks actively, but eventually got into futures - and never looked back.
On the futures, things are quite different, these are MY reasons for favoring futures (not only for a scalper):
I love the futures. I know my way around, I know the ratios to the point where they've become subconscious. It's a great market, nobody just pulls 20 levels of bid or ask in a fraction of a second just because a bird chirped outside or some prop or MM farted and fell off his chair (which you then find out 100ms+ later, and by the time you react it's another 100ms+ and so you modify and it's another 2X100+ms... harrumph), the futures market is very dense and there's always a dick somewhere to unload your position on. Perfect for people with lame internet connections even.
That said, I factually consider the futures my calling. Why?
-

- Tax
- Speed
- Liquidity
- Leverage
- Uptick Rule
- Commissions
- Diversification
- Steadfastness
- Upside potential
- Ability to get a seat
- No insider information
All those things ring in clear favor of futures, stocks are no longer an option for (decent-size) short-term trading. I know it sounds cruel to say this, but futures and commodities were designed for day trading, stocks never were. Stocks are for investors, not traders. If you don't grasp that, the SEC sure does and will do everything to drum it into your head until you understand it. PDT and uptick rule didn't work, let's try banning bullets, conversions, and if that doesn't work, let's try sth else. The only reason why stocks are being actively traded is because it's a niche, and niches will always be filled if there's any money there.
Best Regards,
Scientist.