Why the controversy? Jack Hershey SCT system works just fine.

You beat me to it... I'd add two points though... 1) here's a diagram showing that jreynold212's prediction was more accurate and 2) had the market not done this, Hershey's chart would have never seen the light of day again. It seems that the cultists are desperate to find something, anything to reinforce their denial.
<img src=http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/attachment.php?s=&postid=2109714>

Quote from MandelbrotSet:

It's very obvious that Jack Hershey took jreynolds212 chart where he [jreynold212] made a prediction and drew lines over it, essentially laying claim to it "as if" it were his original prediciton!

LMAO at you guys ... what a bunch of tools!


:p :D :D

P.S. jreynolds212 predicitons were more on point, btw.
 

Attachments

Quote from Trader666:

1) here's a diagram showing that jreynold212's prediction was more accurate ...
Thank you for posting your comparison chart Trader666.

I pulled the original drawing up against a S&P 500 chart and saw that jreynold212's version was a more accurate depiction of what actually happened with the S&P 500's price action, but I don't have the photoshop skills of tikitrader so I couldn't do the comparison. :)

P.S. Yep, it's up there for all to see, hot damn! :D
 
Quote from Trader666:

You beat me to it... I'd add two points though... 1)

Point 1. . . where is the price pane ? You accidentally cut it out of the chart?

Point 2. . . You manipulate your posts.
 
Quote from Trader666:

You beat me to it... I'd add two points though...
More of your "back testing" prowess being demonstrated I see. You never disappoint. One suggestion though... You should examine price and time in your analysis. Though it is nice to see you finally got some chart data... It is a good start.
 
Quote from TIKITRADER:

Point 1. . . where is the price pane ? You accidentally cut it out of the chart?
The price pane is cut out of the orignal post ... tard. Here is jreynold212's original post that Jack Hershey did no less than plagarize! :eek:

Quote from TIKITRADER:

Point 2. . . You manipulate your posts.
No tikitrader YOU manipulated your post, but Jack's chart still did not match the actual price action of the S&P 500 ... these people just won't give up! :D :p
 
wow! big discovery in Jack used somebody else as if he didn't say so himself.

cd23


Registered: Nov 2007
Posts: 183


12-31-07 07:34 PM



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quote from jreynolds212:

This chart demonstrates my thoughts. Sorry, its a rough sketch.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



I annotated your chart and also noted the volume for 2008 as well.
...
 
Quote from nkhoi:

wow! big discovery in Jack used somebody else as if he didn't say so himself.
Yeah dweeb, so thanks for supplying the post where he actually erased it ... as if he could have figured-out how to draw it on his own! :p

here is nkhoi's post ...

Quote from nkhoi:

the better post. :D
http://elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&postid=1821712#post1821712
ps. see what happen when you asked nicely.:)

I don't know about you, but I call this Plagiarism.

Definition of Plagiarims
 
Quote from nkhoi:

wow! big discovery in Jack used somebody else as if he didn't say so himself.

Don't be too harsh... we are still working on our reading comprehension :)
 
Back
Top