If the people who are questioning the authenticity of other traders who share their ideas about trading would just do the work and see if there is some value there, instead of caring about how many contracts are traded, how many ticks per contract, etc...
Reality check: If you are serious about becoming a consistently profitable trader, focus your energy in the proper place, start doing the work. If you don't have any ideas of your own, try some of the ones given freely on this site.