I havent looked at tax trades in a long time,but there may be some sort of tax code which defines the minimum % strike level one must sell that does not negate the long term holding tax advantage
Quote from vhehn:
i emailed him about it. just got his explanation. the tax treatment is better:
"The tax treatment is quite different. On the actual share purchase you can get long-term gains while collecting dividends at the reduced tax rates they command.
If you short two puts instead and they expire worthless your gains are 100% short-term regardless of how long you had the position in place since you never had a 'holding period'. "