Why Is There Even A Debate?

Quote from First Point LLC:

What is there to get? Two groups of people debating because neither can predict the market with any degree of accuracy.

Proves the point... you might as well quit posing the question... you don't get it.
 
Quote from euclid:

Do you mean the past direction or the predicted future direction?

Doesn't matter, the results FOR HIM are usually the same. LOL
 
Quote from Lucrum:

Doesn't matter, the results FOR HIM are usually the same. LOL

You mean like my 1000 point trade call on the YM this year? It's nearly 1/2 way there. When you cats are fighting for every tick, I'll just let the Price Drivers guide me while I am sunning my overly fat self on the beach and dining at Boulud's in the Brazillian downstairs. :)

PS--
Do you live in FLA or just visiting?
 
There is a debate because there are times of day when the price action becomes just downright silly. When this happens, the day traders become bored and to prevent the consumption of too much vodka or weed, they look for the "TA Doesn't Work" debates to engage their brains (which are at risk of turning completely to mush from the intense focus of the first couple hours of trading).

They know that the fundamentalists, who are building up a position to support their opinion of what price should definitely be doing and are deeply underwater while all these idiots keep [buying, selling], are heavily inebriated and stoned most of the day so they can become closer to God while reciting the Trader's Prayer (Please God, let me get out of this trade break even and I promise never, never, ever to trade without a stop again. Amen.) are quite willing to debate any time of the day and night because they're grumpy and want to release a bit of steam, and so we drop in to contribute to these debates to keeps our minds sharp for the next big intraday move.
 
Quote from First Point LLC:

Why is technical vs. fundamental even a debate?

Because Baron pays Surf for making controversial posts, thus generating page views. :)
 
Quote from First Point LLC:

More like trying to see why there's some sort of a feud between the two sides.

Just pick a side and start hurling insults or you'll never fit in around here.
 
Quote from marketsurfer:

You mean like my 1000 point trade call on the YM this year? It's nearly 1/2 way there. When you cats are fighting for every tick, I'll just let the Price Drivers guide me while I am sunning my overly fat self on the beach and dining at Boulud's in the Brazillian downstairs. :)

PS--
Do you live in FLA or just visiting?

Lol

I admit TA works much better when it agrees with capital flows (which "drive" the price, I guess).

I remember the first POMO days. It took me six months of fighting the tape before I stopped reading Zerohedge and just looked at what price was doing, and the habitual injections behind it all. There turned out to be a huge correlation between Benny bond purchases and skying stocks. Only one guy on Zerohedge really got it, and his name was Robot Trader. He just followed the price trajectory....

:eek:
 
Back
Top