Quote from JohnTrader:
You mean that for volatile stocks is better to short the stock itself but less volatile using options is better?
In the above example you mean that BIDU stock would reach the 2% profit and you would closed the position, but the option on BIDU would not reach that 2% profit (or the $200 profit). And in case of shorting DIA, buying options would be easily making $200 even if the stock itself has not reached the 2% limit?
Looking specifically at BIDU with you want to short 100 shares:
BIDU is currently at 108.14 and a 2% drop would require the price to go to 105.98 for a profit of $216 for an investment of $10,814 for your roughly 2% ROI
The BIDU 110 Dec Puts are currently selling for $6.30. If you bought a put and the stock price moves the same 2% down to 105.98 the option would only yield a profit of roughly 124.44 depending on how long it takes to reach that point. That is a $124.44 profit on a $630 investment for a 19.8% ROI. Furthermore, you could have bought 10 puts for only a $6300 investment (leaving $4500 of your capital available for other trades) and made a profit of $1244.40 on the same 2% move.