Why Do Most Retail Traders Favour Technical Analysis ?

I think the problem with new traders focusing on a TA based approach is that they're ignoring the underlying behaviour that drives the patterns, putting the cart before the horse. When I started to think about the interaction between traders that results in the patterns I trade, the indicators became pretty useless.
rather than saying ''double top pattern - short'', say, ''buyers failed to make a new high - short''

So 'trading the behaviour' is just changing the language you use to describe where and why you are taking a trade and what you think is happening, but in the end gives the same entries and the same result since it's all visual and manifests itself as bars on a chart.
 
So 'trading the behaviour' is just changing the language you use to describe where and why you are taking a trade and what you think is happening, but in the end gives the same entries and the same result since it's all visual and manifests itself as bars on a chart.
Bingo. People who insist you need to know why price did what it did or that you even can most of time figure this out are fooling themselves almost always. Why is immaterial, what happened is what matters the most. The goal is to find exploitable patterns. Leave why to the academics and the blithering idiots on CNBC; trading is a business, not an economics seminar.
 
Last edited:
All technical analysis is is following the mountain silhouette backdrop line; the trend is your friend. But as the previous replier said, you also have to be aware of the reasons behind the movement -- don't just blindly follow that line like a horse following a carrot.
mount_everest_top_of_the_world.jpg


(The term Fundamental Analysis shouldn't even exists in a trader's forum...unless you're a longer term short term trader :confused: )



This is a manner of opinion.
If the goal is to "trade", perhaps this has more validity.
If the goal is to profit, make money, then all methods should be considered.
 
Correct me if my premise is wrong
There are only 2 methods in trading T/A and F/A .... correct ?
Why anyone uses T/A because its about pictures, seeing re-occurring patterns on charts. We CAN all agree patterns DO reoccur so hence traders using T/A
Patterns don't always work then again nothing ALWAYS does.
The 2 methods go hand in hand one can act as a filter for the other.
Retail traders lose money because they are putting the cart before the horse in most cases not just because they are using T/A. In trading reality the "method" chosen is not the only thing toward making money. There is so much more.
This is a century old topic anyway no one really addressing the real issue only playing the blame game.

Patterns do repeat, but not in a quantifiable consistent manner--- my eyes were open when i witnessed several very skilled technical analysts making decisions based on a quasi random number generated chart, made to look like a financial chart--- knowing that the chart was from random numbers, but seeing TA pros trying to trade it, was a epiphany for me---

Next, I spent some time at Knight and watched the marketmakers pick off the day traders --and this was years ago--- I realized that you need to come up with something new and different to win in this game. surf

PS-- clearly TA combined with fundamentals makes much more sense overall---these pure price action manual trading guys like the scribblers and straight line types are FOS, there is no question about it. surf
 
The Market Technicians Association are promoting this heavily as fusion analysis.

Interesting--- looks like they have "seen the light"-- I am happy to hear this--- over time, they will drop traditional TA completely if they remain objective. surf
 
Back
Top