Why do ET's Gurus Get Mad When You Ask For Proof?

Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=153024&perpage=6&pagenumber=1

My very first post on this thread said I AGREE with you IF the guru was asking for money, either from selling a system or for personal teaching lessons or any other form similar to those.

The fact that you get overly upset when you don't get the proof you desire from someone who isn't asking you to open your wallet says a lot about who you are.
The fact that you're a Hershey zealot says a lot about who you are.

R. Raskolnikov comes out of the closet

How does it feel to keep defending the indenfisble? Somebody really needs to see a shrink.

LOL ... pathetic. :D
 
Hey Mandel, want to make a bet? Since you say I stalk you (despite the fact that I have many other posts on many other non JH threads) I will NOT post to you or your B-Team and you will not post about Hershey and let's truly see who can hold out longer.

Should be easy for you to win right? It can be easily judged by following post count for anyone here at ET to see and judge.
 
Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

Hey Mandel, want to make a bet? Since you say I stalk you (despite the fact that I have many other posts on many other non JH threads) I will NOT post to you or your B-Team and you will not post about Hershey and let's truly see who can hold out longer.

Should be easy for you to win right?
Jeez, you had to make that post on my thread before I was done editing my previous post. :eek:

Here little doggy doggy, go chase this crayola and sniff Jack's ass.
 
More faulty logic from Rasky the troll... another set of false choices from the dimwit who called me a troll for posting in my own thread when he was trolling there off-topic. :p

A better question is, why do you defend your guru, Jack? Does it cause you cognitive dissonance when the harsh light of reality is shed on your Grobian fantasies?
Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

The flip side is, why do you care? Are you attempting to buy a system or pay one of these guys to teach you to trade?

If the answer is NO, then why do you care what they do or don't do?

If the answer is YES, then I agree 100% with your premise.
 
So, are you game? It would be quite easy for anyone who cares to see who is REALLY the one obsessed with J Hershey.

Come on Mandel Mandel, I'm basically giving you a free win here right? Your credibility will skyrocket here and I'll be destroyed if you can hold out longer than me.

What do you say Mandel? It's such an easy contest to judge.


Quote from MandelbrotSet:

Jeez, you had to make that post on my thread before I was done editing my previous post. :eek:

Here little doggy doggy, go chase this crayola and sniff Jack's ass.
 
Quote from Trader666:

More faulty logic from Rasky the troll... another set of false choices from the dimwit who called me a troll for posting in my own thread when he was trolling there off-topic. :p
LMAO, perfectly stated Trader666.

And the dimwit comes to my thread and makes the offer#!?#!?! :eek: :D

LOL, he couldn't ignore us if he wanted to ... he's been programmed to spend all of his time defending Jack, even there is absolutely no empirical proof that the Jack Hershey SCT trading system even works as presented.

He really should see a shrink if he can afford it.
 
Here he goes again doing what he does best... trolling and trying to obfuscate the topic which really boils down to exposing frauds. Because if someone's a legitimate "guru" they should have no problem backing up their claims.
Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

Love Jones? Take a look at who started this thread (hint, it wasn't me) :cool:

Your first response tells all one needs to know about you. You want your way and, if you don't get it, you obsess and harass people in hopes you eventually do. Just like you started this thread expecting everyone to agree with you and when someone doesn't you can't remain civil and just start spouting lies (like me trading or did trade the Hershey approach) in order to somehow bolster your credibility.

Just so you know, when someone doesn't agree with you, it doesn't mean they are on the complete opposite side of you. My role of "refute the refuter" comes from the fact that you cannot see the other side of the coin and I'm just trying to enlighten you. You only see the world through your own eyes but that doesn't mean you are seeing cleary all the time :)
 
Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

So, are you game? It would be quite easy for anyone who cares to see who is REALLY the one obsessed with J Hershey.
Yes, I will absoutely take you up on this offer when you present your blotter PROVING that your Jack Hershey trading actuall works.

Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

Come on Mandel Mandel, I'm basically giving you a free win here right? Your credibility will skyrocket here and I'll be destroyed if you can hold out longer than me.
LOL, post your blotter against mine and my creditbility would skyrocket here and you'll be destroyed. :cool:

Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

What do you say Mandel? It's such an easy contest to judge.
The only contest I want with is the one where you show what a great trader you are by posting your Hershey trades via a blotter against mine. :)

P.S. Start posting on-topic Swordshit aka Ratshit (same pattern of absolute cowardice when it comes to actually proving he can trade).
 
Quote from Trader666:

Here he goes again doing what he does best... trolling and trying to obfuscate the topic which really boils down to exposing frauds. Because if someone's a legitimate "guru" they should have no problem backing up their claims.
That's because, ultimately, Ratshit is a fraud himself. :eek: :)

He ran like a scared little girl when I challenged to post his trades against mine, all the while calling me names as he backpedalled out of it.

What a troll ... he should try to become a Moderator.
 
Back
Top