why are there no other brokers compete directly with IB?

T

trend2009

IB is a public company, worth 20B. there are lots of traders like me who want to switch, but there is no second broker which can directly compete with IB on the following features at the same time:
1) API support
1) low commision
2) low margin rate
3) broad market to trade

there are so many brokers competing for occasional app/web traders, but no other brokers want to compete directly with IB, why?
 
Last edited:
I only trade futures, so i was able to move away from IB recently.
Now trade with AMP and Rithmic API platform. They are much better for Futures day trading than IB. And you don't need to keep much cash with them as day trading margin rates are so low.

If you trade stocks there must be alternatives to IB for stock trading that can match or beat IB in those first 3 categories you listed

So maybe we need accounts across two or three brokers, that specialise in the instruments we need, just cant do everything in one Universal account like IB offers.

But that wasn't an issue for me as i only want to day trade futures and was able to find an alternative for doing that.
 
Last edited:
Millionaire said:
I only trade futures, so i moved away from IB.
Now trade with AMP and Rithmic API platform. They are much better for Futures day trading than IB. And you don't need to keep much cash with them as day trading margin rates are so low.

If you trade stocks there must be alternatives to IB for stock trading that can match or beat IB in those categories you listed.

So maybe we need accounts across two or three brokers, that specialise in certain instrument types, just cant do everything in one Universal account like IB offers.
More...

I mainly trade stocks. I can not find other equity brokers which can compete with IB. that is why I have no other choice but still stay with IB till so far.
 
Last edited:
trend2009 said:
I mainly trade stocks. I can not find other equity brokers which can compete with IB. that is why I have no other choice but still stay with IB till so far.
More...

Really there are no other Stock brokers with an API, low margin and low commissions out there?

Thats really not asking for much in 2020.
 
Some new brokers are trying, like Alpaca, but they are years away from being able to seriously compete with IB, if ever. This may involve large investment, resources, expertise/people and infrastructure.
Others don't want to deal with APIs when they can make similar money without APIs, saving time & resources.
Some brokers offer institutional APIs and don't want to deal with small traders.
While even if you find another broker, you may run into same problems as you have with IB (whatever those problems are) and then look for yet another broker.
 
trend2009 said:
there are so many brokers competing for occasional app/web traders, but no other brokers want to compete directly with IB, why?
More...
It’s not that they don’t want to, they can’t.

It seems IB accumulated lots of useful features over the years which would be costly to implement because they are needed by some but not the majority of retail and semi-pro traders (even many pros). People who need serious automated trading, for example, most likely are part of a firm that can either implement things in-house or pay good money to a third party.
So you are left with people who produce more headaches than revenues because they need lots of hand holding, especially when you give them choices. “Dumb customer is our best customer” is much more profitable model.
 
Gravity and money.

Gravity in that people seem to flock to larger brokers (for many reasons) which means they get larger which mean more people flock towards them and so on. Of course you still need to offer a great product which they do.

Money. Think about how much money has been invested in the company over the years. That's hard to beat. MOney also breeds security.

IB is hard to beat basically. Someone will try but it will probably take 10 years+.
 
RedDuke said:
What is wrong with Ib? My main and only issue is f...n restarts even of gateway. Otherwise quite good.
More...

Search around on Google. There used to be a free software program (not offered by IB) that enabled the software so it didn't have to log-off every 12 or 24 hours. I don't know if it's still available though.
 
AbbotAle said:
Search around on Google. There used to be a free software program (not offered by IB) that enabled the software so it didn't have to log-off every 12 or 24 hours. I don't know if it's still available though.
More...

search IB controller
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top