I've been watching the show on dvd (god bless Netflix!) the last couple of months and I think it's pretty darn good for a tv series. I'm presently about 2/3 thru the second season (so please don't post any spoilers if you respond!) and I think it's even better than the first. (I haven't read any of the rest of this thread because I don't want to read any spoilers.)
2nd season spoilers to follow: I thought the 2nd season started off slowly but it really picked up after a few shows and is very exciting. There's always so much going on w/lots of twists and turns. The plot twist w/the seemingly meek cute blond sister (the bride, who seemed to be a minor character) turning out to be one of the major bad guys was very cool. The actress did a great job in a very difficult role. (She also looked hot as hell in her short black wig.) I expect we'll being seeing that actress in movies soon, she's really got the acting chops. And the whole way they had Mason starting out as a coward and ending up a hero had a nice thematic arc, another good actor, and he surely had one of the most spectacular deaths ever in series tv. Sutherland is a fine actor, always believable, and he really holds the show together, it wouldn't work nearly as well w/a lesser actor.
I think the weakest part of this second season is the storyline involving the daughter, it's not as integrated in the plot as it was in the first season, but it is tied-in w/the overall story and Elisha Cuthbert has to be one of the most beautiful young women working in film or tv, and what's more she can act. If she continues to grow as an actress (I think she's still a teenager) she could be a major film star one of these days.
Yeah, it's tv, and full of plot holes and can be dumb and unbelievable, but they're not pretending to be Shakespeare. It's good dumb fun and I think that's all they mean it to be. It's an action movie disguised as a series, more like a mini-series than other wkly shows and I can't help but get caught up in whatever bizarre plot twist they will come up with next.
DVD is a great way to watch a series like this at your leisure. No commercials, there are 4 episodes to each disk so if I get really caught up I don't have to wait a wk for the next show. (Or even longer since tv series usually have a bunch of "down wks" during the season w/reruns or when they don't show at all.) After I finish 24 I plan to try Alias on dvd next, I've read a lot of good stuff about that one too.
I hope Seasons 3 and 4 are as good as the first two!
Harold