Haha...

I would never do that. Why would I want to create some kind of animosity here on a public venue allowing folks to squabble over the merits (or lack thereof) of another poster. Not cool. Suffice it to say however that if this were to happen (which it won't in all reality)... The folks brought together would have as much can-do positive attitude and willingness to have fun as they would technical acumen. Perhaps more. It would be a fun shop, of that you can be assured. And it would kick ass and win. There is no doubt in my mind.
But to all the other great points made on the thread... "all great points" lol.
I realize now, who wants to run a hedge fund anyway. I just want to trade my own money.
I guess the spirit of the original post was spawned because I think bringing together a small collective of the right individuals each with unique talents and personalities, of which I know there's more than enough here on ET to pick from, collaborating together could outperform the indexes and the funds.
I guess what I envisioned would be more of a club. And thats nothing new. But the strength would lie in its people. And I think an actual physical location, as opposed to cyber-chat would be key. There's a certain synergy when people actually work together in person that can't be replicated via on-line chat or Skype. It is what is. We are human after-all. This whole concept of
"good traders are loners" is complete BS imo. They need not apply. I want smart party folk.
So like I said originally, re-location would be an issue.... so in reality it can probably never happen. But it would work in an ideal world where a handful of folks could all relocate in some cool city and come into the office daily. It would be a fun time, thats for sure. There'd always be a bottle of whiskey and a keyboard to smash. And NO healthy organic snacks. Smoking encouraged.