Who Posts All Their Trades ?

galvinlee888 · Mar 25, 2011

Only those who want to sell $3999 course or promote their web site/book will post their "selected " winner trades

Amateur or paper traders did post all their traders

None of the real profitable traders will post their actual trades here to give away their edge for free.

cornix · Mar 25, 2011

Posting trades and giving edge away are two very different stories, especially as for discretionaly trading methods.

galvinlee888 · Mar 25, 2011

Quote from cornixforex:

Posting trades and giving edge away are two very different stories, especially as for discretionaly trading methods.

This make my day and weekend

luisHK · Mar 25, 2011

Quote from GrandSupercycle:

Does luisHK post all his trades ?

If so where ?

LuisHK doesn't trade, he's reading your posts and learning what not to do

cashcarewins · Mar 25, 2011

I post all my trades in real time on twitter at http://twitter.com/cashcarewins .

Real time means the twitter feed is connected to my trading platform so I don't have to think about posting them.

It's a 90 day experiment, you can read more about that and what I am trying to do in my journal at http://www.cashcarewins.com .

BTW, the first person to read this will be the first person to know about that outside my family.

Petsamo · Mar 25, 2011

Quote from cashcarewins:
50 percent Ask ESM1 130125

I have no clue what that is.

cornix · Mar 25, 2011

Quote from galvinlee888:

This make my day and weekend

You really believed that knowing someone's entry points equals to knowing all nuances of his trading decisions?

cashcarewins · Mar 25, 2011

Quote from Petsamo:

I have no clue what that is.

In futures trading you buy the bid and sell the ask. Here is what the string looks like in code:
string str = qty.ToString() + " percent " + e.Order.Side.ToString() + " " + e.Order.Instrument.Name.ToString() + " " + e.Order.ExecutionList[e.Order.ExecutionList.Count - 1].Price.ToString();

qty is converted to percent, Order.Side is bid or ask, etc.

Fwiw, e is the callback structure from the server api.

3/24/2011 10:55:40 AM 50 percent Ask ESM1 130125

Date time qty side K price

Hope the alignment worked out.

cashcarewins · Mar 25, 2011

Quote from galvinlee888:

None of the real profitable traders will post their actual trades here to give away their edge for free.

I assume you've never traded. What edge can anyone possibly give up by showing their trades. I do it in real time, but even that is after the trade. By the time a human can process it the best trades will never trade at that price again, so you'll end up getting all the losers and only most of the winners.

I thought about showing all my orders, but that would just be so much noise, I might place 5-10 orders for each execution.

I think the 'real profitable traders' who do this kind of thing are not interested in doing it for the money.

dwpeters · Mar 26, 2011

A number of traders post their trades on profitly. I think that people trying to sell something should post their trades but I don't see the point in amateur's posting theirs or pro's just trading for themself. Why should I post mine? It's not an audited track record and there is enough information overload in the world already.