Quote from Mom0/pH0x:
geez, i'm not trying to be malicious, i just have observations and share them candidly, i don't pull any punches but i'm not a vicious slanderer either, just honest about how i see things...
so, the traders you have lost to echo, what do they cite as reasons for leaving? (rates i'm guessing?) and the guys that have come over from echo, what did they not like about it there? just out of curiosity what do you see as echos strengths/weaknesses/niche vs you guys'?
As most of you know, Echo was formed by a couple of ex Bright Traders. They have always been gracious "competitors" - I like Rob and Jeff.
Early on, in fact the reason I first came on ET - a "manager" was basically trying to recruit our traders, and compensating traders for helping to do so. This resulted in all sorts of really erroneous comments here about our Firm, my brother, my family etc.
I came on, without an alias to simply set the record straight. I called Jeff D. at Echo, and he promptly put a stop to all the mudslinging etc. And, was unaware of any such activity. All good from Jeff.
Echo merged with Van Buren, another group formed by BTraders. Echo then merged/joined/partnered with (not sure of the legal transaction) with Pax, their clearing firm at the time. At some point, they became part of the Merrill Lynch family. I spoke with Rob about that time, and was assured that the "same team was in place" (which actually made me feel better).
Now to your question. Yes, we have lost traders to lower rates over the years. Sometimes we didn't have a location nearby. And, we've had some leave to come back later for various reasons.
We had a group actually test both firms for several months before deciding that they wanted to be part of the Bright team. Some other Echo transferees needed/wanted to be part of our PairCo team with their live chats, daily data base updates etc. Rates were negotiated. Some came over because they were not allowed as much capital usage as we offering at the time. Some wanted to part of a mentoring group. Some liked the black/gray boxes offered to our people.
Overall, some traders have been to several firms... some never leave, LOL. IMO, I think good management exists at both Firms. We have chosen to stay private, they didn't, simply a management decision.
I appreciate your candor, and don't mind discussing any of this in general.
Trade well,
Don