who can tell me whats the effect of "MACD"

[Cweixing]

Quote from flyingforget:

I find MACD is more useful in time chart than in tick or volume chart

the MACD cross the zero line regularly in time chart

but it cross the zero line unregularly in tick chart

you do not know where the price will go in tick chart

Thank You!

 

[astral]

Quote from flyingforget:

the momentum increases or decreases so rapidly in tick chart

it it hard to grasp it

Maybe, just MAYBE, it's your inability to correctly interpret indicators. When you would analyze the momentum of price, caused by volume of course, then you might interpret indicators completely different.

If we would look at MACD, you should learn to analyze HOW and WHEN certain formations (crossovers of lines, or the histogram) occur. In the end, when you are at that skill level, you will know WHY indicators lag.

It's so absurd, this place of full of people who rely on indicators
(derivatives of price), yet the all have one thing in common, they make little or no money. Their fundamental mindset relies on "edges".