When not to trade?

I do not hold into the announcement but will trade in the morning of and the afternoon of, after the initial volatility of the announcement.


I do the same. (That tends to work out quite conveniently for me, anyway, given my time-zone.)
 
if the filter is so great it should be part of the method, if its not part of the method yet then may be it will be some day, but as of now it should be disregarded
OK...my non-trading day criteria is part of the methodology.
 
in reality all criterias are subjective, until they become part of the method :)

trader decide what criterias he makes objective by including it in the method and what not (by setting it aside) :)
That's what I've been trying to tell Scat. It's all part of the method and has been for a long time. Thanks.
 
I suppose it's pretty debatable the extent to which the labels "opportunist" and "grinder" are necessarily mutually exclusive. :)
 
My advice to ET'ers is that Scat is right and he is wrong. Subjective filters are bad during trading in the moment. Predetermined TECHNICAL FILTERS can be the best thing you've ever done for your bottom line! These kind of "filters" have been back tested through data or valuable experience! Is that the key Scat? A filter can be a technical and objective criteria and not always subjective?

Difficult to be sure exactly what you're asking, but let me try to explain with this example....

Let's say the ES makes a "matched low @ ____", but you decide to not take the trade (assuming your strategies include playing "matched lows") because "the RSI isn't oversold enough". The RSI in this case is a "filter". The fact that it's not oversold is objective by traditional understanding... whether it MATTERS in this case is "subjective".

If it turns out that the "matched low" criterion was correct... passing up the trade because the "RSI was not oversold enough" was a mistake.
 
Last edited:
To trade the way I trade, I believe that things come back to be shot at a second time. If I miss it, so what? There's always another pattern, another instrument. That's not an excuse to be lazy. It just means to stay loose. My worst trading problems come from being locked in and then new information comes in saying this trade has lost its mojo. That means either contrary selling/buying or just chop or time running with no progress. If something is telling you this trade just isn't working, you probably should beat your stop.
 
I suppose it's pretty debatable the extent to which the labels "opportunist" and "grinder" are necessarily mutually exclusive. :)
I must ask the question...how many of you disregard your "book of setups" and still enter the price action momentum sometimes because it's too irresistible? I haven't done this in many years. I consider myself a grinder.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top