Quote from dbphoenix:
You've been spinning in that particular circle for hours, but the fact remains that you didn't trade the posted system, skimpy as it is. Therefore, whatever you did says nothing about whether it works or not.

Quote from dbphoenix:
Actually, you haven't done anything of the kind. But if believing that you have makes you feel better, then knock yourself out.
I suppose I could also point out that if you actually were right, you wouldn't have to make so many posts trying to convince everyone that you're right. But seeming to be right is important to you, whether you are or not.

Quote from dbphoenix:
The word is "tenets", not "tenants". And what you posted was not the system provided. If you had fleshed it out before you began trading, there might be something to discuss. But you just made it up as you went along.
As for the "2 bar charlie system", what it boils down to is "trade the trend". What a revelation. Would it have made me money today? Perhaps. First I'd have to fill in the blanks.

Quote from dbphoenix:
Yes, I did answer the question, even though it's a stupid question for someone who claims to be a trader. Whether I made money or not would depend on how the trade was managed. There's a lot more to trading than entries.