What to look for in a Prop Firm?

Quote from billsafari:

Well, after spending about 30 hours reading every single thread and post on here (literally )about Prop firms I am no further then when I started.

After reading posts about Les, tuco, etc. I am thouroughly afraid to even fund an account with a prop firm.

What should I be looking for? A SEC registration # or something?

Just because they are registered are they any more solvent? Or their financials are just public?

Does requiring a S 7 or 56 mean they are registered?

Are any Prop firms SIPC insured?

Are there any Prop firms where if another trader blows up himself and the company I will still get my money back?

The one year lock up is a SEC rule?

I am assuming K1 is better then a 1099 for losses?

I've posted regarding experiences with Lake Street and Braod Street with one response. Are these firms Taboo?

When I was reading Broad Street's trader agreement I noticed in the fine print it says my funds would be used in case of another Traders blow up. Also, they said I need a 56 but then it says they are not FINRA or NASD registered.

It also said they can hold my funds for any reason with respect to payouts. Is that normal?

Are any of these firms taking on any risk at all? Or are they last in line to pay up on a blow out?

When we sign the contract are we at the mercy of these people? Can they just hold our profits and payout when and if they feel like it?

Do we have any recourse or are we completely bound by the contract?

Just when I thought I had a grasp on what to look for I feel totally lost as how to asertain the correct information.


What are the top tier firms( in your opinions)?

I do not want to have to worry about payouts or some other traders blowing up and the firm using my capital to fund their losses?

What firms are not necesarliy top tier but where one does not have to worry about money and payouts?

I am at the point where if I do sign with one of these firms I feel I will have to record every phone call and conversation and take screenshots or pics of my balances just to protect myself.

FYI: I would be remote. Must have buy call/put options abvailable to me. Don't need training. Would trade my own style not theirs.
The max I would be willing to fund with is 5k.

Someone please guide me on this? Thanks a lot.


I would ask a friend. That's best.

Firms that want deposits or training fees are usually some form of shit. It might also be a sign that their risk management sux. They might be using your money to control some or all of their risk.

I get annoyed when they ask for money. They seem like beggars to me. It's also an insult b/c I don't lose much money and they still want money. Look, if I lose money, I'll write you a check.

The lockup sux too. If you want to leave, you can't get your money back for a year. Annoying.

What I would do is find out how long the firm has been in existence. Good firms have been around for at least ten years and are established.

Go to the firm and talk to management. Look at the traders. Look at the office.

If you see mook mofos, thugs, degenerates, people dressed like homeless people, and so on and if you hear them speaking busted English or talking like criminals, well, you will probably get f*cked soon or later if you join the firm.

Clean office, better firm. Look at their bathroom. Clogged toilet equal shitty firm. No pun intended. Some of these traders don't know how to wipe their a$$ and flush toilets. Not a joke.

In one firm, the compliance insisted that traders shower daily. No joke again.

Payout. This is really important. Ask how often you get paid. Ask about ALL fees including commission. Prop firms seem secretive about this. Get this in writing. Bi-weekly paid out is good. Monthly is bad. Bi-monthly? Tell them to go f*ck themselves. Who gets paid bi-monthly. Fishy stuff. Pay out on demand is best.

I would keep the least amount of money at the firm possible and withdraw money as often as you could.

What's your reason for joining a prop shop?

At Worldco, a trader next to me would joke that prop shops are chop shops.

I gave you some brutal truths that you probably won't find in the prop shop ads or hear from the prop shop guys.

It's also nice if the prop shop orders lunch. Convenient. Breakfast is good, too. Better prop shops gave me free food.

Also, try to see the profit and loss of the traders when you visit them. They should be able to pull it up on the computer screen. If the firm is good, they should not have to hide this. In fact, good firms with good traders would show it off to you. I noticed this. It might give some indication of the type of traders they have.
 
Quote from SnakeEYE:

I got one.

p.s. i meant to say, senior trader or vice president at a prop.owner would be much better.if you didn`t get the idea..

:p

Joke.
 
Quote from Don Bright:

We do not hold initial deposts for 12 months.

All the best,

Don [/B]

I thought the one year lock up was a SEC rule. Why do some firms adhere to this and others do not?
 
$5k does not give you a lot of choices. In my opinion, it's also not enough money for option trading. The better prop firms that allow option trading ask for around $100k. [/B][/QUOTE]

Considering all the uncertainty around these firms 5k is all I would be willing to risk.

For my strategy 5k(with 6 :1 or 10:1) would be enough. I use options( front month, sometimes weeklys) to iniate my trades eventually creating a strangle in which I trade the stock around them the whole time pulling profits/or legging into the options when needed. It reduces some of my profits but I won't get blown out. And with the volatility lately, over the course of the month both legs have been profitable.

I mainly trade the beast BIDU. Sometines GS and a few other others.
I'm a small guy. I only trade 100 to 300 shares. But with Bidu going up 10 and then down 10 in a single day thats all I really need.
 
I mainly trade the beast BIDU. Sometines GS and a few other others.
I'm a small guy. I only trade 100 to 300 shares. But with Bidu going up 10 and then down 10 in a single day thats all I really need. [/B][/QUOTE]

-------------------------------------------

Imagine how much fun trading that way with $250K would be......Cheers...Bob
 
Here are a bunch of questions you should be asking:

1. Do you allow traders to trade remotely?

2. Do you require Series 56/7?

3. What are your commissions rates and is there a minimum ticket charge?

4. What's your payout split?

5. Do you pass back exchange rebate fees?

6. Do you offer advanced order routing mechanisms? Do you have access to midpoint routes and dark pools? Please elaborate

7. Do you have special relationships with floor brokers (floor routes)? If so please describe the fee and rebate structure?

8. Do you have a capital contribution requirement? If not, please describe any risk management parameters (such as max drawdown per day) that you have.

9. Please elaborate on how much buying power you provide? If this depends on capital contribution, please elaborate on that too.

10. How do you process payouts to your traders?

11. What trading platforms are available to traders? Do you charge a platform fee?

12. Please describe any other fees that you require traders to pay?

13. What type of training do you offer and is it free for members?
 
10:1 on options is going to be hard to find with 5k. you'll probably get offered 2:1 or 3:1. Options are risky cause shorting calls can lead to unlimited loses.
 
Quote from EvOTrAdEr:

10:1 on options is going to be hard to find with 5k. you'll probably get offered 2:1 or 3:1. Options are risky cause shorting calls can lead to unlimited loses.

I really don't write options unless I put on a spread or leg into a long. I need the leverage to trade around my options using the underlying. I may spend only 500 to 1.5k on options just as a partial hedge in a given month.

Broad Street offers options with 5k. They seem to have a lot of fees. Here they are. Is this about average for a firm?

K1 annual filing fee. 100.00
FINRA Non-member processing fee. 85.00 initial
FINRA disclosure processing fee 95.00 per incident
FINRA Annual Systems processing fee 30.00
FINRA US termination fee 30.00
Outside brokerage account fee FINRA monthly 25.00
FBI background check fee 20.00 initial
Fingerprint fee 21.00 initial
CBSX inactivity fee. 100.00 monthly

Then basic admin fees.
incoming wire 10.00
outgoing wire 25.00
returned check 50.00

This doesnt include platform fees.

Can I eliminate any of the FINRA fees since I am already registered with them (6 and 63 expired, current series 3)?

Here are some more potential fees if I want any of the following. No prices mentioned.

NYSE level 1
ASE - b/a l, last quotes
Nasdaq level II
Nasdaq Total View
US indexes
BATS book
Direct edge book
NYSE open book(specialists order book depth)
ARCA book listed
ARC book OTC.

I use TD and their weak tools, Level II and charts and do just fine.
 
Are you kidding me?? You'll need to make a lot of cash to cover these!

Quote from billsafari:


K1 annual filing fee. 100.00
FINRA Non-member processing fee. 85.00 initial
FINRA disclosure processing fee 95.00 per incident
FINRA Annual Systems processing fee 30.00
FINRA US termination fee 30.00
Outside brokerage account fee FINRA monthly 25.00
FBI background check fee 20.00 initial
Fingerprint fee 21.00 initial
CBSX inactivity fee. 100.00 monthly

Then basic admin fees.
incoming wire 10.00
outgoing wire 25.00
returned check 50.00

This doesnt include platform fees.

Can I eliminate any of the FINRA fees since I am already registered with them (6 and 63 expired, current series 3)?

Here are some more potential fees if I want any of the following. No prices mentioned.

NYSE level 1
ASE - b/a l, last quotes
Nasdaq level II
Nasdaq Total View
US indexes
BATS book
Direct edge book
NYSE open book(specialists order book depth)
ARCA book listed
ARC book OTC.

I use TD and their weak tools, Level II and charts and do just fine.
 
Back
Top