You must lose real money in the real market to learn how to trade successfully.
I would say major in economics and minor in psychology,
You must lose real money in the real market to learn how to trade successfully.
In real trading my son, prices can go up and down 40 ticks several times within minutes , knocking your stops and wiping your ass boy
On many of the good moves there's also a small window of opportunity where a very tight stop can be used. Those opportunities normally happen AFTER event and not before which is why it's normally best to trade AFTER the event and not before. If you trade before the event you can't usually use a small stop meaning it's really hard to get a decent risk/reward on the trade. Hence, the better traders tend to trade after the event when they know they've got momentum on their side. If you buy the low, how do you know momentum is going to materilise? You therefore need people to be wrong and then realise they're wrong and the only way they'll realise they're wrong is if price starts to move higher.
Yes, you're right, price can swing up and down very quickly a lot of the time.
But not if everyone wants it.
Then the probabilities say a) it's not going down so a tight stop can be safely used, and b) get ready for lift off.
Use a tight stop in such situations and get ready to regularly accept 3:1, 4:1 maybe even as high as 10:1 winners.
Do I get losers? Of course, but I take these in my stride because I KNOW, and I mean REALLY KNOW that when I get winners, more often than not they'll be big.
You say the reason why so many lose in this game is because they use small stops. The problem with large stops is you're going to get both winners and losers in this game but because of the large stop it's basically impossible (for most) to have significantly higher profits on winners than their losers. That is why when traders finally understand how to approach the markets they still can't get much above breakeven, if at all. The profits they earn when right basically cover their losses when wrong.
So I say the reason so many don't win overtime is because they use large stops.
As said above, all large stops do is stop you making major R/R when right. So the key to trading is to use tight stops at the right time then your winners will more than pay for your losses and have plenty left over in the plus column.
When is the right time - when everyone wants it (or doesn't want it for shorts).
Do you reckon they get in AFTER the event or at the START of the event and DURING the event?
I'm not saying any of this is easy, trading is not easy, even for the best because of the perversity that dogs ALL traders ALL the time. So work at it. Look for evidence of the 7th Law and the concentrate on what happens afterwards.
I'll post some more setups over the next few days. This one isn't the best, I'd grade it as complex, others are far simpler.
View attachment 166747
When people first get introduced to the 7th Law they think, ok got it, look for smackdowns and then trade the reversal of that move.
That's one way the Law works. But they normally miss the far more subtle part of it.
A strong market that keeps its strength is also a market that is minimising participation because traders want to get long but don't want to pay up, preferring to wait for some sort of reaction that 'normally always comes'. But it doesn't so a) keeps them out at present levels and/or b) forces them to pay ever higher prices if they have to get long (or cover shorts).
So think of the 7th law as working both ways. Personally I think the buy high trades are the better ones to spot and probably more profitable because then you (almost) know that everyone wants it whereas if price is coming off a low there's the higher possibility that the move back up is just a reaction to the recent down move.