Whenever I trade futures I use limit orders, and they get filled acording to queue on my system... If Im #20 on the line, then I expect the 20th contract to be mine.
I think ES/NQ/YM futures are way to volatile to trade em for 1 tick profit. Every once in a while it would move too fast and put you down 5-10 ticks... is working all day to have it all blown out in 2 minutes... You have a better shot at doing this at less volatile instruments... highly liquid, with not much movement, and preferently penny stocks, that way you avoid SEC fees, that can be killers for large orders on pricy issues. LU is great for this kind of strategy, so are, JDSU, SCMR, VTSS, SUNW, SIRI, CIEN, ASTM
Another thing is that if you´re planning on using limit orders, as you probably are, then you can´t simulate your excecution... best shot is to start it with 100 share blocks... fees will kill you, but just worry about gross results and scale up as you get better...