What is Technical Analysis? Why does it work?

Because everyone else is using it? It is the study of human emotions/price?

It is how price works?
%%
Something like that; I am number 9 . The same deal if people see stuff[any stuff] on sale@ 50% they may buy, like a stampede of a herd of buffalow or bears .
Actually TA is the study of price + volume..............................................Wisdom is profitable to direct
 
The Geometric Brownian Motion model of stock pricing (used in Black and Scholes model) is a universally acceptable model. This model supports market randomness. I didn't say there was not an edge to be found it just isn't found by predicting direction.
 
Everyone will say bullshit no doubt and i tell you i'm not about prove anything to anyone but a systematic approach using TA can generate trade success rates well north of 70% with a baseline R1 with room for more R on the fat pitch setups , runs of 10 consec winning trades happen with minimal relative consec losses . Using the 4 measurable tangible variables of price action a way of identifying recurring patterns is more than possible ... trend volatility range momentum with an entry signal setup is the closest thing to a holy grail you will find . Using dynamic SL and position sizing with a variation of kelly criterion you can get a smooth fast curve .. it is possible , no-one said its easy though , everyone of my trades will stand of to a 1R with stop loss same as tgt as %age and bat at .75 , you need rules with flexible dynamic intuitive inputs , a thinking system that is binary . Static systems will never stand the test of time , you need to code price action within a dynamic market condition , takes IQ and tenacity with the ability to think outside the generally useless generic trading world . My take on this is the less people that can do this the better , throw your macd rsi stoch MAx indicators in bin for they are not the path .... good luck to all ps forget anything with low % success rates with overly ambitious R , the way to a fast smooth curve is high baseline % with all work on improving R , drawdown is the enemy and low % is the pathway to high drawdown , high drawdown = low position sizing which inturn = pathetic curve . Mediocre in = crap out ..... good luck , the answer is not on ET ;-)
Rules with intuitive inputs what do you mean by that? Are you intuitively picking a direction?
 
It is not definitions that are missing about TA.
I would say that it is the study of chart patterns.
Not everyone uses it. It's a minority among others.

Then ?

Facts (more or less) precede theories.
However you are begging the question...
Can you reach that "It works" conclusion?
TA has multiple rationales, empirical studies,
That conclude for and against your conclusion.
But don't stop and don't even bother about that.
Make your own judgement, find an overlooked bug.
A hackers won't stop because it's said impossible.
Let they think it is so. And make it by yourself.
Trading is also a form of art of exploitation.
Like everything involving progress is.
It's not about average but outliers.
Not the majority but only a few.

Do not ask those kind of questions,
What matters is what you can do with it.
Not what people make or tell you they make.
You have to learn to discover, try it by yourself.
You either want to be the expert, or ... the sucker.
SELF INDULGENT
 
Because everyone else is using it? It is the study of human emotions/price?

It is how price works?

sure.

it works because people get inside info and use TA as cover :)

obviously not everyone has access to inside info, that why so few consistent winners, if any. Information link collapses and end of success.
 
Because many days the market is not random. For example, a report on unemployment comes out say better than expected, so it creates a fundamental action and prices rise. Then using TA, one can pick a setup that has a statistical probability of greater than 55% to work. Also, one can use TA to stay out of the market for example if prices are moving sideways. Also, when I statistical probability, I mean that you back tested it either using a report feature on your chart software or some other way. You can also look at tracking sites for example, my system that was once number 1 over year's worth of real time data that traded real money for investors was based on TA.
 
Last edited:
If a trader has a very high rate of winning trades. And winning trades means that he take very big parts of almost every move. So not just taking a few ticks here and there. Doesn't that prove that markets are not random? In best case I would even say that only turnings of the direction might be random, and even that is not sure for me.
 
If a trader has a very high rate of winning trades. And winning trades means that he take very big parts of almost every move. So not just taking a few ticks here and there. Doesn't that prove that markets are not random? In best case I would even say that only turnings of the direction might be random, and even that is not sure for me.

An easier question to answer might be: Can a trader have a very high rate of winning trades if given known random, computer generated, simulated prices to trade?

I've pondered this question years ago and concluded: The price actions are a random series of non-random patterns.
 
The price actions are a random series of non-random patterns.

I agree on "non random patterns", but I don't agree on "random series".
Random series in a timeframe can be part of a non random pattern in another timeframe.
THE timeframe does not exist. Every "thing" is part of a bigger "thing" and can become non random because of that.
I can tell more about his but will not for evident reasons.
 
I agree on "non random patterns", but I don't agree on "random series".
Random series in a timeframe can be part of a non random pattern in another timeframe.
THE timeframe does not exist. Every "thing" is part of a bigger "thing" and can become non random because of that.
I can tell more about his but will not for evident reasons.
Just to be clear, my original post is saying, for a simple example:

Non-random patterns:
123123123
543543543
111111111

Combined in a random way:
123123123111111111543543543111111111...
 
Back
Top