Quote from ubertuber:
Show of hands from successful Proflogic Traders whom have graduated from student status and are applying this methodology exclusively as taught on an intraday basis.
UT
Undoubtedly debate, even heated and colorful exchanges, should be allowed to flourish, particularly when argument is rightly being deployed for and against a particular system which has been (or is being) sold elsewhere. When the sparks are flying it brightens up any discussions forum. Such debate here is even more important when claims of its success have been implicitly, apparently or even explicitly made.Quote from MandelbrotSet:
.. this thread, it is after all, a thread which is designed to question his system, which I do have a right to do, after all IT IS A FREE WORLD.

Quote from Cheese:
My view is that buying any gurus plans or ideas is an utter waste of money. The reason is as simple as gets. If it is successful you would make your fortune from it and not sell or want to sell your system/ideas to a gullible public or to noobs also frequently naive and gullible.
![]()
Quote from Equalizer:
Hey FrothLogic,
still haven't heard the name of the University that ... ahem... "sponsors" you. Unless of course by sponsorship you mean they allow you to hire a room to fleece noobs out of nearly 4K.
Indeed, Bill made such a statement in "the other thread", but his kabana boy (our impartial moderator) decided to delete not only our requests for verification, but Bill's original statement as well. Funny about that!
Thus, due to the deafening silence, one can only conclude that your statement was complete and utter BS. No surprise there.
Now watch FrothLogic use every trick in the book trying to slither his way out of this, like not answering the question, not staying on topic, answering a question with a question, personal attacks, etc, etc, all irrelevant preprogrammed responses. Synchronously funny and sad.
To all potential victims who are about to have $4K depart from their wallets, Caveat Emptor.
Quote from Sushi:
hmmm. Jack Hershey may just be the same as profligic. More evidence surfaces.
Quote from Cheese:
My view is that buying any gurus plans or ideas is an utter waste of money. The reason is as simple as it gets. If it is successful you would make your fortune from it and not sell or not want to sell your system/ideas to a gullible public or to noobs also frequently naive and gullible.
![]()
Quote from Equalizer:
Clearly you understand what "edge", "crowding" and "alpha decay" mean from a trader's perspective, at least at an intuitive level. Now watch someone - with possibly ulterior motives - attempt to debate that point of view.