The vast majority of coaches are people who cannot trade profitably (FACT), they realise that after years of trying they cannot trade profitably and they take this route. It's a much easier option for them to 'coach' and grind out a $50k p/a living rather than continually lose money trading. There is a seemingly endless queue of new and not so new traders who are willing to hand over their cash to these people. Throughout my trading career I have paid for the services of various coaches, I didn't ever pay mega bucks but over time when you add it up it's not an insignificant amount.
My last experience of coaching was an 'ex prop futures trader' who charged £79pm for access to his trading room. I stuck with it for 2 months, I put down his poor performance in the 1st month due to bad luck. He continued to do his ring consistently in month 2 that's when i bailed. All of the bravado and veneer of profitability strewn all of twitter was washed away as he called loser after loser with tight stops lol. I think at one point he made 9 losers in a row. After I cancelled I then got emails asking why i stopped subscribing lol When I replied that i stopped as 'you were continually doing your arse on a consistent basis' no reply was forthcoming.
He wasn't a coach. He was a vendor without a viable product.
The more important question is why you believed you needed a coach in the first place, and, beyond that, why you found it necessary to pay for the services of several.
Do you have a thoroughly-tested and consistently-profitable trading plan? If so, why do you need a coach? If not, why not?
While it's true that "there is a seemingly endless queue of new and not so new traders who are willing to hand over their cash to these people", that's because there is an endless queue of new and not-so-new traders who don't want to do the work, who'd rather let somebody else make the calls. This relieves the "trader" from all responsibility, but that carries a price.
When wannabees who don't want to do the work of developing and implementing a robust trading plan practically beg these vendors to take their money, one can hardly blame the vendor for doing so.
Picks and shovels.
There will always be those who assume responsibility for their trading lives and those who mill around waiting to be told what to do. Every wannabee is free to choose one path or the other.
I have always liked bird dogs better than kennel dogs. You know, ones who will get out and hunt for food rather than sit and yelp.
-- "Engine Charlie" Wilson, once Secretary of Defense
