What Decides Your Vote?

A

AAAintheBeltway

I read a commentary that referred to a study done some 40 years ago by a group of political scientists. They discovered to their surprise that the most important factor determing how people vote was party affiliation. It was considered a bombshell because academics had always assumed that factors like a candidate's position on issues, his general character, his affinity with voters, etc were more important. Recent polling has confirmed that contemporary voters have the same attitudes. Party affiliation tends to trump other factors. If anything, people are becoming more likely to vote straight party lines. The red state/blue state presidential divide carries over to other races. In fact, this may be the Republicans' secret weapon in the upcoming election.

Part of this may be attributable to the parties becoming more idealogical and more idealogically pure. Democrats clearly are very liberal and Republicans are more uniformly conservative. Individual issues, even hot button ones like abortion and affirmative action, have taken a back seat.

Personally, I don't have a problem with this. I think if anything we could benefit from more party unity and less free lancing by congressmen. In the old days, the Speakerof the House or the Senate Majority leader could pretty much guarantee his members votes on important issues. It provided accountability. now, it is hard to blame a party's leaders or the Presdient when individual Members act like free agents and take positions more to get on the TV shows than to help their party or constituents.

So my question is, what determines your vote? Will you more or less automatically pull the straight party line lever or do you vote ala carte, based on a careful weighing of positions, character, etc?
 
He he. SOME coin could influence my thinking.
AAA, its not much of a surprise that you feign surprise at this supposed study-nor that it would effect your vote.
You are "that " demographic.
 
"what determines your vote?"

well - as an observer from abroad i'd say it's those funny voting machines without any paper that will put out any result that's been determined long before.
 
Illinois eliminated "straight party" (i.e. one punch) voting in 1998. It hasn't changed election patterns an iota. Those who voted straight party with one punch now do the same with twenty punches......
Quote from AAAintheBeltway:

I read a commentary that referred to a study done some 40 years ago by a group of political scientists. They discovered to their surprise that the most important factor determing how people vote was party affiliation. It was considered a bombshell because academics had always assumed that factors like a candidate's position on issues, his general character, his affinity with voters, etc were more important. Recent polling has confirmed that contemporary voters have the same attitudes. Party affiliation tends to trump other factors. If anything, people are becoming more likely to vote straight party lines. The red state/blue state presidential divide carries over to other races. In fact, this may be the Republicans' secret weapon in the upcoming election.

Part of this may be attributable to the parties becoming more idealogical and more idealogically pure. Democrats clearly are very liberal and Republicans are more uniformly conservative. Individual issues, even hot button ones like abortion and affirmative action, have taken a back seat.

Personally, I don't have a problem with this. I think if anything we could benefit from more party unity and less free lancing by congressmen. In the old days, the Speakerof the House or the Senate Majority leader could pretty much guarantee his members votes on important issues. It provided accountability. now, it is hard to blame a party's leaders or the Presdient when individual Members act like free agents and take positions more to get on the TV shows than to help their party or constituents.

So my question is, what determines your vote? Will you more or less automatically pull the straight party line lever or do you vote ala carte, based on a careful weighing of positions, character, etc?
More...
 
Vendetta, self-interest - especially economic, a single issue, looks, revenge, personal apperance, a health sprinkle of altruism.

That's how I voted last week.

And man are Republicans dead meat.
 
Who would Jesus vote for?

And on this Tuesday morning I saw Jimmy Swaggart on tv in front of the map of the middle east talking about wasting $1 billion dollars every 3 days in Iraq and the horrors of war. I wonder who Jimmy votes for?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top