Volume--- how to use it and WHY
- Thread starter marketsurfer
- Start date
It's been shown ad infinitum on this thread that price/volume bars create the exact same highs and lows (unless you think they don't, LOL), volume is irregular (much as time is) and that price ultimately ends up at the same place no matter what road it travels ...
P.S. Isn't it funny how these GURU's (jack hershey, ProfLogic, spydertrader, etc.) refuse to offer any type of PROOF that their system actually works, while demanding proof from others.
Too funny.
Quote from MandelbrotSet:
They are great for observing order flow, otherwise there is essentially no difference between them and the minute bars.
But when he starts talking about Physics as it relates to intraday trading (Big LOL), along with pretending that his trading is perfect (while never making a Live Call or showing his Blotter) over the intervening years, while we continue to have the same-old-same-old arguement, it's really just a waste of time and actually pretty boring.
Coupled with all the other nonsense he's pulled (insults, threats, name calling) as well liberal use of multiple-alias, he's [ProfLogic] really just a TROLL who continues to populate the Trading Boards in search of fresh meat.
Yuck!
Even someone with "zero" experience in the market can SEE the difference between Minute charts and Constant Volume Bar Charts.
Whenever you find your testicles to trade live in front of real people, you let me know.
IndeedQuote from Trader666:
ROTFLMAO
Right ... except YOU couldn't figure-out which of the charts that I posted was a constant volume chart, and another poster had no problem figuring it out, LOL.
Whenver you find your testicles to make a LIVE CALL (under your ProfLogic alias) and post your BLOTTER (under your ProfLogic alias), you let me know. :eek:
<b>Posts: 2659
07-06-09 04:42 PM
ROTFLMAO
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quote from MandelbrotSet:
LOL, you mean this guy who put on a Short trade today with his Market Call as the market was rising??
I'm pretty sure that's a multiple-alias for ProfLogic. It would be great if a Moderator could confirm that information. </b>
is that really the wizard??? :eek:
07-06-09 04:42 PM
ROTFLMAO
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quote from MandelbrotSet:
LOL, you mean this guy who put on a Short trade today with his Market Call as the market was rising??
I'm pretty sure that's a multiple-alias for ProfLogic. It would be great if a Moderator could confirm that information. </b>
is that really the wizard??? :eek:
Yep, I'm pretty sure it is.
He writes in the same self-grandiose manner, he has the same flunkies following him around as ProfLogic does, and he's put in some jibes-and-jabs which make me think it's him. But it's easy-as-pie to have a multiple-alias on ET, so I would need a Moderator to confirm my suspicion.
Or of course, ProfLogic could come on here and state unequivocally that it isn't him, at which point if I find out that it is, he will be branded as the biggest liar on ET.
He writes in the same self-grandiose manner, he has the same flunkies following him around as ProfLogic does, and he's put in some jibes-and-jabs which make me think it's him. But it's easy-as-pie to have a multiple-alias on ET, so I would need a Moderator to confirm my suspicion.
Or of course, ProfLogic could come on here and state unequivocally that it isn't him, at which point if I find out that it is, he will be branded as the biggest liar on ET.
Quote from MandelbrotSet:
It's been shown ad infinitum on this thread that price/volume bars create the exact same highs and lows (unless you think they don't, LOL), volume is irregular (much as time is) and that price ultimately ends up at the same place no matter what road it travels ...
P.S. Isn't it funny how these GURU's (jack hershey, ProfLogic, spydertrader, etc.) refuse to offer any type of PROFF that their system actually works, while demanding proff from others.
Too funny.
The highs and lows are the same but the cycles, which are what are important, are different.
You aren't going to name the software are you?
I'll trade you heads up in front of live people Jimmy.
Strap it on and lets go. I'd love to have the opportunity to embarrass you in front of an audience. That should be PROOF enough.
What is proff?
Quote from MandelbrotSet:
Right ... except YOU couldn't figure-out which of the charts that I posted was a constant volume chart, and another poster had no problem figuring it out, LOL.
Whenver you find your testicles to make a LIVE CALL (under your ProfLogic alias) and post your BLOTTER (under your ProfLogic alias), you let me know. :eek:
I told you which was the minute chart. Your software is unknown so we will never know if your volume bars are correct.
Lets trade live Busboy. Put it up.