Volume analysis is to be discarded as it is "too much information"

Volume analysis of any use?

  • I believe in using volume analysis

    Votes: 162 58.5%
  • I discard volume analysis in my trading

    Votes: 71 25.6%
  • I really don't know

    Votes: 43 15.5%

  • Total voters
    277
Quote from Tradesall:

And judging by his refusal to post proof of his accumulated profits I'm sure his account is just as small
Haven't you heard?

Nobody on the site is "worthy" ... ROTF. :p :D :)
 
... just in case you geniuses missed it

Here's a excerpt from his recent emails to past students......

***

UPDATE: CLASSES - SPACE IS BECOMING LIMITED

I have finalized the scheduling for ALL upcoming classes: Australia (August 30th, 31st, & September 1st), Singapore (August 26th, 27th, 28th) & Hong Kong (August 22nd, 23rd, & 24th) Classes for August, if there was any interest, please contact me. The dates, times and locations are listed on the website at: ************.

If you have already contacted me with your interest, thank you. Please remit your deposit soon to confirm your seat at www.paypal.com to the account of ************ . If you haven't yet contacted me, please do so as SPACE IS BECOMING LIMITED. I need to insure there is enough room for all that wish to attend. To repeat, this will also be my last trip overseas for classes.

He has repeated it would be his last trip overseas to Asia ever for at least the past 5 years!! Every time he markets the seminars it's the last time because he wants to spend more time with his son/wife/family/trading/etc.

In my view alot of the past students have now moved on due to the dubious claims and poor results they got. These seminar gurus are a dime a dozen in Asia and they share a few common traits, the most obvious making wild claims and not having to back it up. Oh, and none of them trade live.

LOL, just another crap vendor/hustler!:p
 
Quote from MandelbrotSet:

... just in case you geniuses missed it

Here's a excerpt from his recent emails to past students......



As stated many many many times before, if what I do is such a joke and fraud then it should be easy for a trading genius like youself to show me up trading live and in real-time but your continued refusal shows you are simply talking out of your many many many a$$holes.

How's your short today working for you?
Little hard to concentrate on your losing trades while your rehearsing isn't it?



Have you checked out the trailer for the Musical yet?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBjMXfAn5gU

See if you can pick up Manny.
 
Quote from sakhter:

If you spend as much energy arguing than you do trading than I wonder what your account balances REALLY look like.

When do you guys actually trade? Are you constantly hitting refresh? I see shit talking responses to posts within a few minutes.

That being said.

Tradesall, seeing that you respond to ManderbolSets responses within minutes, makes me wonder if you are using dual-alias.

ProfLogic.. stop trying to sell shit & stop trying to prove/sell your uber-skills. The only people that attend seminars are really in line to join the 98% club.

I don't also understand why anyone here talks shit about proflogic's trades in the first place. If his trades blow up, and are fabricated. Who the fuck cares? Even if you think hes a snake oil sales man, some people want snake oil. After they get that rash, they know to get better oil.

I can't speak for the troll Manny his alias Tradersall but I trade with RCG and have for 15 years.

I don't mention what I do outside this forum in this forum. I do not sell or promote ANYTHING here. The afore mentioned tolls like to promote the site though.

You make my point exactly as well. If I'm such a blow-up artist then it should be a piece of cake to out perform me but evidently it's easier to verbally harass me than to do the work to prove me wrong on their own or not prove it works and ignore me.
 
Quote from ProfLogic:

Sorry, was never asked to prove account size but it doesn't matter, Manny (your other alias) will never agree to a trade-off because you can't trade.

There's this great site I know called c............vestor.
 
I can bail you out, Prof, just as I did Jack Hershey. You post your TS code, and I'll vouch for it. Not that people think Jack Hershey is any less crazy, but that if someone can show a backtest that works....well, that'd be the first step. My 2 pennies.

This whole thread is one big pissing contest. Nothing too constructive in it. Unbelievable.

What's lost on many here is that systems have up and down periods, and we don't have any clue one way or the other when somebody is there unless you can see their real trades.

This thread is in strategy trading, and I haven't seen any strategy being discussed. Volume is helpful in very few cases, and Jack Hershey's system is the only one I've ever seen where a volume condition makes a huge difference.

For you proflogic, I've only read esoteric ancient threads about what I believe is your use of the ergodic oscillator. If I have you confused please tell me. I used to have systems on futures trading with the ergodic oscillator, but I found them to be massive curve fits.
 
Back
Top