Volume analysis is to be discarded as it is "too much information"

Volume analysis of any use?

  • I believe in using volume analysis

    Votes: 162 58.5%
  • I discard volume analysis in my trading

    Votes: 71 25.6%
  • I really don't know

    Votes: 43 15.5%

  • Total voters
    277
Quote from Xspurt:

One last example of how PA and sentiment indicators lag volume clues.
--------------

So while B1S1 is waiting for his indicators to tell him what the sentiment is the volume readers are waiting for him to enter the market and push their trade on further.


another excellent description, thanks again Xspurt

sosueme
 
Quote from MandelbrotSet:

You can start with yourself you lying, multi-alias, shill.

Wow, please show me where I lied, what other aliases I use or what paid product I promote.
Your paranoia must be hard to deal with. I can't believe that one of my first posts in this forum was to defend one of your statements. I won't be doing that again.
 
Quote from Chart_Precocity:

--------------
I can't believe that one of my first posts in this forum was to defend one of your statements. I won't be doing that again.

Boy you are a quick learner.
Only one lesson and you have come to grips with ET already.

sosueme
 
Quote from Chart_Precocity:

Wow, please show me where I lied, what other aliases I use or what paid product I promote.
Your paranoia must be hard to deal with. I can't believe that one of my first posts in this forum was to defend one of your statements. I won't be doing that again.
Actually, the reality is you posted numbers, to make it seem like you weren't just a "one post shill" (like I said you were).

Your first real post was criticizing what I said, not defending it ... but hey, thanks for confirming that you're a lying sack of shit (and an idiot, to boot). :p

fake posts 1-5

fake posts 6 and 7

first real post

LOL, what a troll. :D :D :D
 
Quote from Buy1Sell2:

------------------------------------------------
Necessary items for successful trading:

==Prudent risk management
==Prudent risk management
==Prudent risk management
==Prudent risk management
==Entry, Exit system based on price and a scant few indicators that reflect market sentiment.
------------------------------------------------

------------------------------------------------
Unnecessary items for successful trading:

==volume analysis
==gap analysis
==head and shoulders
==inverted head and shoulders
==ascending triangles
==descending triangles
==rule of 10
==T day theory
==PPT theory
==option greeks
==news
==megaphones
==scaling in/scaling out
==all in,all out
==etc. etc.
==volume analysis
-------------------------------------------------

Forgot one major unnecessary item and that's "pairs" trading.
 
Quote from MandelbrotSet:

Actually, the reality is you posted numbers, to make it seem like you weren't just a "one post shill" (like I said you were).

Your first real post was criticizing what I said, not defending it ... but hey, thanks for confirming that you're a lying sack of shit (and an idiot, to boot). :p

I got turned on to this site a few days after I got my new email computer. If there is something illegal about testing my email by having a site send me emails please have someone of authority tell me that.

You really must be in the habit of pissing on people here to talk to people like you do. I hope your life improves someday man.

Oh, is it ok if I say I use ensign here, everyone? I read the rules but didn't see anythins stating I couldn't mention my charting program.
 
Quote from Buy1Sell2:

------------------------------------------------
Necessary items for successful trading:

==Prudent risk management
==Prudent risk management
==Prudent risk management
==Prudent risk management
==Entry, Exit system based on price and a scant few indicators that reflect market sentiment.
------------------------------------------------

------------------------------------------------
Unnecessary items for successful trading:

==volume analysis
==gap analysis
==head and shoulders
==inverted head and shoulders
==ascending triangles
==descending triangles
==rule of 10
==T day theory
==PPT theory
==option greeks
==news
==megaphones
==scaling in/scaling out
==all in,all out
==etc. etc.
==volume analysis
-------------------------------------------------

Indicators are certainly NOT required for successful trading.

Where is your evidence that they are?
 
Quote from Xspurt:


So while B1S1 is waiting for his indicators to tell him what the sentiment is the volume readers are waiting for him to enter the market and push their trade on further.
 
Quote from Buy1Sell2:

Forgot one major unnecessary item and that's "pairs" trading.

Quote from Buy1Sell2:

I trade all in, all out -----------------
You may be on the right track soon!!

------------------------------------------------

OK I got it now, you simply forgot how you trade.
I haven't come across that before.

B1S2, have you given any thought to trading a real account with real money instead of just posting garbage to ET.

It is a worthwhile thing to do.
Anyway, just something to think about.


sosueme
 
Quote from Chart_Precocity:

I got turned on to this site a few days after I got my new email computer. If there is something illegal about testing my email by having a site send me emails please have someone of authority tell me that.

You really must be in the habit of pissing on people here to talk to people like you do. I hope your life improves someday man.

Oh, is it ok if I say I use ensign here, everyone? I read the rules but didn't see anythins stating I couldn't mention my charting program.
ROTF ...

It took you long enough to make up the story after you were caught in (yet another) lie. :p

LOL ET
 
Back
Top