There is no correct answer as to how MM books are run, as it all depends on how their VIX future position fits into their portfolio. There are numerous ways they could be hedging their futures, so it all depends on how they want to close the trade.
In the case of the Feb expiry, the high print doesn't necessarily mean the street was short the future; in fact, it could easily mean the exact opposite. If they were long the future and hedged it by selling options, they would have to buy those options back en masse on the open, driving up the price.
To be honest, though, I've never understood people who hold large future positions into the print without participating in the HOSS opening. Leaving yourself open to the risk of something you have no control over and can easily become disconnected from the true state of the market seems like a losing proposition to me, unless you're consciously making a bet on where you think the print will be in the morning.
In the case of the Feb expiry, the high print doesn't necessarily mean the street was short the future; in fact, it could easily mean the exact opposite. If they were long the future and hedged it by selling options, they would have to buy those options back en masse on the open, driving up the price.
To be honest, though, I've never understood people who hold large future positions into the print without participating in the HOSS opening. Leaving yourself open to the risk of something you have no control over and can easily become disconnected from the true state of the market seems like a losing proposition to me, unless you're consciously making a bet on where you think the print will be in the morning.