i agree with you, however i may be trading a new instrument, but I'm still trading the same index, and trading the XSP weeklys is pretty damn risky considering you have to hold trades longer because of the larger spreads. If i see an opportunity to trade the E mini sp, it's not physically possible to open an account to trade futures quick enough to participate in whatever move I'm predicting.
Today I bought XSP at .80 and sold at 1.40, thats almost 100% gain, the spx went from 1403 to 1419, thats 16 points. With a margin of 500 I could of made about a 150% return. Not only that but with options i have to hold onto my trades to make up for the high spreads caused by lower liquidity.
So I'm sure you can see why I would see e mini's more appealing
And i may sound like some cocky kid who thinks he wants to make fast money, but i've been trading for 2 years, went to homeschool so i could trade, watched the market everyday, and lost a lot of money earned at $7.50 dollars an hour. In the past two months i started trading the weeklys, and it's been the best decision i've made yet... until of course I start trading futures