Quote from PAPA ROACH:
Just for the sake of a better investment in my opinion, let's take the $102,000 of money that 8,000 shares of UNG represents and put it in these.
$34,000= 1,589 shares of CHK $21.40
$34,000= 1,433 shares of HK at $23.72
$34,000= 1,003 shares of STR at $33.88
These will trade with a bull market in natty, AND collect the forward curve. UNG loses on contango and will not make a cent in the major spread between Sep and Jan.
We will compare these investments on your timetable.
So, either today or Monday will be the 1 month mark, (Sunday is the 30th).
Let's tally up the score:
Buying 8,000 shares of UNG at $12.75 against $11.13 close =-(12,960.00). This is actually very lucky that it is not a much further loss; UNG ran out of shares and is closed-ended for the moment and is trading a generous 16.5% premium to the underlying (it should be trading at $9.29 if they make more shares available, netting a loss of -$27,680.00)
Buying 1,589 CHK at $21.40 against $23.59 close =+$3,479.91
Buying 1,433 HK at $23.72 against $21.91 close =-($2,593.73)
Buying 1,003 STR at $33.88 against $34.90 close =+$1,028.16
Net gain of $1,914.34 against a UNG net loss (lucky only) of -$12,960
Again, UNG is the shittiest way to play natural gas. Wait until UNG rolls from October futures into November, it's currently over a one-dollar contango spread. OUCH!!!!!!