This case is such complete and utter horseshit.
5 years after the "flash crash," and this is the guy they're holding up as its poster boy? lol, really, this is THE BEST the SEC and CFTC can do?
They're going to crucify this kid for no other reason than to pat themselves on the back, and show mom 'n pop that they're on task. How many traders at the CME have received messaging violations since that became a thing? Seriously, think back to what your messaging ratios have been and give me a good reason why THAT'S not evidence of spoofing?
They say he made $40mm since the flash crash, and anectdotally list some of his bigger P&L days, but they make no mention of his losing days. For all we know he made $900k on flash crash day and lost $2mm the next.. so what?
If we're going after individuals because they (somehow, inexplicably) cause markets to go down, then I want Lloyd Blankfein arrested for causing my 401k to plummet during the financial crisis, and Jamie Dimon hung, drawn and quartered because my house depreciated 10%.
Doesn't sound logical, because it's not. This case is no different.
Again, some random dude trading on EXCEL SPREADSHEETS is to blame for flash crash? The way the indictment reads serves no other purpose than to poison the jury pool, and make certain this a quick win/slam dunk for the government.
This really is too much; SEC/CFTC incompetence on display.