Quote from harris_tch:
Hey Scientist. I trade dax aswel. can u kindly tell me what u mean by native stops on dax and what advantage it has over ES?
Thanks
Oh come on Harris, are you for real? You are moving, what, $120K worth of face value per contract, and you don't even know your exchange rules? Don't you think you should know this stuff at gunpoint? And then have the chin to ask me to do the research for you?
But hey, since you asked so kindly, here they are:
Eurex &
Globex
Eurex uses
native MKT, STP, GTD, GTC & RFQ orders.
Globex supports none of those orders, it only offers
simulated (broker-based) MKT, STP, GTD, GTC orders.
Globex doesn't even have MKT or STP orders. Basically, everything on Eurex is native while most orders on Globex are only simulated by broker. If you want anything native at Globex, you'll have to be happy with STP-LMT or MKT-2-LMT orders.
That is a big difference, in many respects. As a matter of fact, it even influences the way the market moves in various situations.
Here's a hint - Queuing; LMT orders can happily sit (and queue for as long as they like) anywhere on Globex, while your STP and consequent MKT orders aren't even in the market. Basically, they only get triggered the moment your "imaginary" stop is hit, which means first your broker has to detect the price being hit, then feed back by placing a supported order (all of which adds lag), then that order is of course last in the queue to be executed at that price, and most likely you will NOT get outta there during a nice breakout, it can add at least a tick slippage (and lots more if you're trading size).
Timing can make a lot of difference. On Eurex, your stops can be sitting in the market just as long as the limits (i.e. forever). You can hit or lift at market without doubt of execution, and leave your stops sitting there without worries, because they WILL get filled (no limit on your stops). I.e. you can turn off your machine, bomb-shell your broker's server farm and walk away without worries. Well... scratch the last bit.
But before you only think about trading/fill/queue/timing applications, think also about the fact that with sim orders, your broker is the "weakest link". You basically depend on your broker & server to get in/out. If he's down, anything can happen, particularly if you're already in your position.
With native, on the other hand, well either the orders are at the exchange (in which case you're safe) or they're not (in which case it doesn't matter anyway).
More importantly, during an exchange crash or limit-up/down situation, anything can happen with sim orders, too. Your MKT or STP orders to get out alive can be happily ignored. Nothing you can do about it. That's Globex for you.
Again, I'm still not saying either of them is better, because they both have their own implications (stop gunning, for example, is super fun on Globex). And that's why I say you need to figure this yourself, because it depends largely on your risk profile and trading plan. I trade both exchanges every day, and have different approaches for each.
~S