Quote from masterm1ne:
I'm sorry but I'm really confused by this statement, as it seems an honest one.
If anything, I controlled my losses very well. What is killing me is the degree of winning trades I've had. Every single winner I had in the last few months only showed profit for a day or two, and was stopped out eventually, for either a small loss or small gain. I've tried every type of stop - Volatility based, price bar based, etc. It almost always is hit. Trades often go in the initial direction that I want, but will come back and hit my stop loss eventually.
I had a few large winners that covered my small losers in the first month or so... this is the foundation of trading I'm sure, as most traders winning percent is not much higher than 50%. Obviously I've suffered an anomaly, as I know my big edge is correct near 95% of the time, but because of the timing of my entries, it of course has not demonstrated that. Also, if I were entering at RANDOM, I should have more winners than I have had recently, especially over this period of time!
I have been trying to catch large moves as my big 'edge' called them. However, this is proving to be quite more challenging that it was in my back test(s)...
When I find something that has high probability when I back test it, it almost never turns out the same way in a forward test. As I posted before a simple pattern that reoccurs has like 80% probability of at least offering a scalpers profit as long as the entry and exit rules are followed. Of course I do a few trades on it they are all losers!!!
Regardless, I need to go back to paper trading. I think the problem is probability/edge, and the fact my account is small doesn't help...
Pay no mind to nkhoi. He supports Jack Hershey, and deletes posts frequently whenever the obvious is brought to his attention.
If you don't have 100+trades in your backtest, this could be another reason all of them lose after finding 80% "edges." Remember that trading futures you should utilize systems that either point significantly in one direction or are overbought/oversold such that your edge in a single day are around 50-60% win percentage, or 70+% swing 1-5 days, and 85% more than 1 week. If your strategy with the 80% win percentage isn't profitable this far out, then this is why your optimizations and walk-forward results haven't been profitable. You probably notice a lot of stop outs which comes from too lengthy a trade duration and too tight a stop.