Tulip mania: the classic story of a Dutch financial bubble is mostly wrong

was there a way to short tulips?

I don't think so. That is why bubbles grow like that, the inability to bet against them. Same with Bitcoin's last year's raise. Maybe it has nothing to do with it but once the futures came into the picture...

Edit: The very first short did happen in Holland in the same century 1609, but it was a stock, the Dutch East India Company.

Very interesting story:

 
Last edited:
Assigning great value to something essentially near worthless or in the case of bitcon, easily copied, duplicated, fungible

Bubble

Worthless, fungible... That defines well the USD, or any fiat money. Your government prints boatloads of it. I miss your point, here. On which premise do you state that bitcoin is worth less than USD? Because it is not printed by the Federal Reserve? Let me remind you that 1 single bitcoin is worth $8,600 USD at present. What's worthless and what's not? Both are backed by hot air, hypocrisy, lies and empty promises. But, as a matter of fact, one is worth 8,600x more than the other. And that's a fact. Not a belief.
 
Worthless, fungible... That defines well the USD, or any fiat money. Your government prints boatloads of it. I miss your point, here. On which premise do you state that bitcoin is worth less than USD? Because it is not printed by the Federal Reserve? Let me remind you that 1 single bitcoin is worth $8,600 USD at present. What's worthless and what's not? Both are backed by hot air, hypocrisy, lies and empty promises. But, as a matter of fact, one is worth 8,600x more than the other. And that's a fact. Not a belief.
Actually the dollar is backed by a government that is willing and able to do all manner of things to ensure that it's value doesn't fall to 0. Bitcoin is not. In that way they are vastly different. I've got no horse in the bitcoin race other than interest in the block-chain technology, so the idiocy posted on both sides is pretty apparent. If you want to be a nihilist, nearly everything of value is based on "hot air, hypocrisy, lies and empty promises", from gold to truffles. Like all nihilism, it's a rather pointless belief to hold in the real world.
 
Worthless, fungible... That defines well the USD, or any fiat money. Your government prints boatloads of it. I miss your point, here. On which premise do you state that bitcoin is worth less than USD? Because it is not printed by the Federal Reserve? Let me remind you that 1 single bitcoin is worth $8,600 USD at present. What's worthless and what's not? Both are backed by hot air, hypocrisy, lies and empty promises. But, as a matter of fact, one is worth 8,600x more than the other. And that's a fact. Not a belief.
Ah but the dollar is not worthless. You can use it to pay your taxes!
 
Back
Top