Tribute to Brooks

[padutrader]

they are in the business of selling you courses

he says trade the pull back.....that is what he says in his books.

is that wrong? is what he says is it fraud?

i agree what he says may not be easy....but he never says it is easy

on the contrary he says it is hard

unlike the others who say trading is easy

 

[SPX Options Trader]

he says trade the pull back.....that is what he says in his books.

is that wrong? is what he says is it fraud?

I just personally think it's rather wrong or unethical or immoral....for someone to teach/sell someone something...if they are basically failures themselves at it,

You wouldn't get surgery by a doctor...who has killed his past 8 out of 10 patients, would you...

 

[maxinger]

The bible and trading book are at the opposite end.

For the bible, you must have faith. You don't question it
with science/technology.
Don't try to understand how human can survive inside the big
fish for 3 days.

For the trading book, don't put your faith in it no matter
how famous/popular the author is.
You better question what the book says.
After reading it,
go to Mount Doom in the Lord of the Ring, and destroy it.
Discard what you have learned, then develop your
own trading strategy.

 

[padutrader]

who has killed his past 8 out of 10 patients

if i knew that beyond a doubt, then no.

but here i am not suffering if i read his books......and use it on demo ...

all the products that are sold in this world are unethical.....they do not provide proof that they work......you decide and try...

or just ignore

that is the way i see it

of course you can call it unethical and that he should be jailed and not pay him

that is ok too

but with your permission permit me to see it differently

 

[padutrader]

You better question what the book says.
After reading it,
go to Mount Doom in the Lord of the Ring, and destroy it.
Discard what you have learned, then develop your
own trading strategy.

yes of course you must.

to question it you must buy it first!

but to call someone a fraud and a arse licker.....

what are you going to question? that you must trade the pull back? does that not work...?

 

[SPX Options Trader]

here i am not suffering if i read his books......and use it on demo
that is ok too

In every transaction deal...there is a winner, and a loser -- or someone who gains more benefit, and someone who derives less gain.

I think students who purchase so-called courses, books and subscriptions...are fools, while the entertainer/teacher gets rich selling/shilling his wares.
This is reality, sadly. Wolves take advantage of the weak, maybe naive, sheep masses.

I truly do, hope, you become a millionaire from that magical information you bought...but I wouldn't bet on it.
That entertainer/teacher/charlatan...meanwhile, is laughing all the way to the bank.

 

[padutrader]

In every transaction deal...there is a winner, and a loser -- or someone who gains more benefit, and someone who derives less gain.

I think students who purchase so-called courses, books and subscriptions...are fools, while the entertainer/teacher gets rich selling his wares.
This is reality, sadly. Wolves take advantage of the weak, maybe naive, sheep masses.

I truly do, hope, you become a millionaire from that magical information you bought...but I wouldn't bet on it.
That entertainer/teacher/charlatan...meanwhile, is laughing all the way to the bank.

so you think' trade the pull back' is magical information?

that is all he says.

but he also says it is hard to do so ......i am sorry to say he is NOT promising millions.....i have to correct you there

 

[padutrader]

I think students who purchase so-called courses, books and subscriptions...are fools,

i respect your view and i am going to leave it at that.

i enjoy my life and whether i am a fool or a genius or a jackass is not going to change that

 

[padutrader]

truly do, hope, you become a millionaire

thank you for your good wishes.

i do not live on hope and i know i can make a good living from trading the pull back like many others before me.....

a million is not my target so i doubt i can hit something i did not aim at.

i am not that good.... but it makes me feel warm inside, that you think, i am that good.....

 

[speedo]

Discussion on ET