Trend Following Research

Quote from Gabfly1:

Was she a vendor at the time of the MW interview? Or did she become one after the second MW book had made her something of a celebrity in the trading subculture?

You did say that you had read both of my books and seen my film?
 
Quote from Trend Following:

You did say that you had read both of my books and seen my film?
Quote from Gabfly1:

...I actually read both of your books. I didn't much care for the first one, as you may or may not recall, but the turtle one was a good and interesting read. I enjoy trader interview books à la Market Wizards. But I would hope that none of the traders you will be presenting are also vendors. That would just cheapen the exercise.
 
Quote from Gabfly1:


Still trying to understand 'vendor' and why it was used. Would you care to share anything about yourself so there can be a real conversation?
 
Quote from Trend Following:

Still trying to understand 'vendor' and why it was used. Would you care to share anything about yourself so there can be a real conversation?
Don't be obtuse, Mike. You're a smart guy. If any of the interviewees in your upcoming books are selling courses, seminars, "mentoring" or some such, then they will be conducting themselves in your interviews with a view to sell their wares to your readers. Their responses to your questions will be framed accordingly. It's what they do; it's who they are. And as I said, when I buy a book, I don't want to pay for someone else's advertising. Do you think an interview of a hack like Larry Williams will come anywhere close in value to an interview of, say, a Paul Tudor Jones or a Michael Marcus (both from the first MW book), or even an obscure but capable trader who doesn't automatically don his plaid jacket when you step into his office?
 
Uncannily for a free market supporting financial trader board, ET attracts in ordinate number of capitalist hating socialist free loader types.

They hate anyone who sells things and have quite the entitled attitude. I am at a loss why this is accurate. Perhaps they have been burned by the market machine so many times, their love has turned to hate??

Not only this, but as soon as they sense you have achieved a modicum of success in this business-- be it as a vendor, writer, guru, fund manager, or trader--- the hate can become vicious.

This is particullarly the case if you "step outside" the bounds of commonly believed trader mistruths ie TA works, trends are real, etc-- as long as you toe the religious line-- you will be accepted.


Quite a sad commentary.
 
Quote from marketsurfer:

Uncannily for a free market supporting financial trader board, ET attracts in ordinate number of capitalist hating socialist free loader types.

They hate anyone who sells things and have quite the entitled attitude. I am at a loss why this is accurate. Perhaps they have been burned by the market machine so many times, their love has turned to hate??

Not only this, but as soon as they sense you have achieved a modicum of success in this business-- be it as a vendor, writer, guru, fund manager, or trader--- the hate can become vicious.

Quite a sad commentary.
Unlike Mike, you genuinely are obtuse. You're the real deal.
 
Quote from Gabfly1:

And as I said, when I buy a book, I don't want to pay for someone else's advertising.

Still trying to understand why this term 'vendor' was used by you in conjunction with my new book -- a book that by my description features 11 top traders. Explain that connection in your mind? How/why did you even decide to use the term 'vendor' based on what I said and my prior background?

The reason I asked if you wanted to share something personal is it seems your criticism so far, without any explanation, says more about you than my work. Willing to listen.
 
Quote from Gabfly1:

Don't be obtuse, Mike. You're a smart guy. If any of the interviewees in your upcoming books are selling courses, seminars, "mentoring" or some such, then they will be conducting themselves in your interviews with a view to sell their wares to your readers. Their responses to your questions will be framed accordingly. It's what they do; it's who they are. And as I said, when I buy a book, I don't want to pay for someone else's advertising. Do you think an interview of a hack like Larry Williams will come anywhere close in value to an interview of, say, a Paul Tudor Jones or a Michael Marcus (both from the first MW book), or even an obscure but capable trader who doesn't automatically don his plaid jacket when you step into his office?

Larry Williams has much more to provide to a retail trader than Tudor Jones or Marcus. Seriously, get real---
 
Quote from Trend Following:

Still trying to understand why this term 'vendor' was used by you in conjunction with my new book -- a book that by my description features 11 top traders. Explain that connection in your mind? How/why did you even decide to use the term 'vendor' based on what I said and my prior background?
I didn't say your interviewees were vendors, because I don't know who your interviewers are. I just noted that I hoped they wouldn't be. The reason I said this is because I have read a book or two of trader interviews that were interspersed with "traders" who were also vendors. Their "interviews" were of no value to me.
 
Quote from Trend Following:

Still trying to understand

Save your breath. You're arguing with a nobody. His "insight" on the other thread is: let your profits run. (Gee, did he think of that one himself?)
 
Back
Top