Quote from kc11415:
Over some number of months I've seen a variety of criticism of Jai, some less than constructive, and some of which is just healthy skepticism.
I wasn't certain the main themes of his presentation would be directly applicable for my interests, but I wondered if any reading-between-the-lines or side comments might be of interest for me.
For what its about, what he was offering via this seminar seems fairly upfront and legit. My impression is that the paid seminars he mentioned are designed to get newbies grounded in the basics, or at least wake them up to the range of principles and skills in which they should become grounded for TA-based trading dependant upon the skills and disciplines of the trader.
Is this a grounding attendees could establish through:
1) reading the classic books;
2) surfing relevant chat rooms;
3) other self-study;
4) and careful record-keeping and review of trading experiences?
Probably for many of them. However, if they were likely to achieve results through such venues, then they'd have already learned that they did not need paid seminars. While I have availed myself of such self-directed study venues, it has taken me quite a while to progress up the learning curve. (Though I'm still inclined to continue this route for my circumstances.)
Of the 2-3 dozen people who attended, it seemed like a number of them were sufficiently new to the field such that they might not yet be ready for the self-study route to trading. Their exposure to the markets thus far seems as investors not as traders. While appearances can be deceiving, it seems like a few of them should probably remain as investors and stay away from trading.
( i.e. Why do so many free trading presentations/seminars have some 60-70 year old guy who answers his cell phone while still sitting in the seminar? If they can't figure out how to activate silent mode on their phone, then will they ever understand a Level 2 display? Indeed, that should be a pre-requisite for admission to free seminars; prove that you know how to activate silent mode on your phone.)
For the wanna-bes, perhaps Jai's coverage of the demands and responsibilities of trading might serve to scare them away. If not, then they're fair game for the rest of us.
Just my two cents.